Nuclear Medicine, Department of Internal Medicine, IRCCS AOU San Martino-IST, University of Genoa, Genoa, Italy.
J Nucl Med. 2013 Jun;54(6):894-902. doi: 10.2967/jnumed.112.113928. Epub 2013 Apr 16.
This project aimed to investigate the metabolic basis for resilience to neurodegeneration (cognitive reserve) in highly educated patients with prodromal Alzheimer disease (AD).
Sixty-four patients with amnestic mild cognitive impairment who later converted to AD dementia during follow-up, and 90 controls, underwent brain (18)F-FDG PET. Both groups were divided into a poorly educated subgroup (42 controls and 36 prodromal AD patients) and a highly educated subgroup (48 controls and 28 prodromal AD patients). Brain metabolism was first compared between education-matched groups of patients and controls. Then, metabolism was compared between highly and poorly educated prodromal AD patients in both directions to identify regions of high education-related metabolic depression and compensation. The clusters of significant depression and compensation were further used as volumetric regions of interest (ROIs) in a brain interregional correlation analysis in each prodromal AD subgroup to explore metabolic connectivity. All analyses were performed by means of SPM8 (P < 0.001 uncorrected at peak level, P < 0.05 false discovery rate-corrected at cluster level; age, sex, Mini-Mental State Examination score, and center as nuisance).
Highly educated prodromal AD patients showed more severe hypometabolism than poorly educated prodromal AD patients in the left inferior and middle temporal gyri and the left middle occipital gyrus (ROI depression). Conversely, they showed relative hypermetabolism in the right inferior, middle, and superior frontal gyri (ROI compensation). The sites of compensation, mainly corresponding to the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLFC), showed wide metabolic correlations with several cortical areas in both hemispheres (frontotemporal cortex, parahippocampal gyrus, and precuneus) in highly educated prodromal AD patients but not in poorly educated prodromal AD patients. To provide evidence on whether these metabolic correlations represent preservation of the physiologic networks of highly educated control subjects (neural reserve) or rather the recruitment of alternative networks (neural compensation), or a combination of the two, we performed metabolic connectivity analysis of the DLFC in highly educated controls as well. The correlation sites of right DLFC partly overlapped those of highly educated prodromal AD patients but were less extended.
The present findings suggest that highly educated prodromal AD patients can cope better with the disease thanks to neural reserve but also to the recruitment of compensatory neural networks in which the right DLFC plays a key role.
目的:本研究旨在探讨高教育水平的前驱阿尔茨海默病(AD)患者认知储备(代谢储备)对神经退行性变的代谢基础。
方法:64 名有记忆障碍的轻度认知障碍患者,在随访过程中发展为 AD 痴呆,90 名对照者接受了脑(18)F-FDG PET 检查。两组均分为教育程度低亚组(42 名对照者和 36 名前驱 AD 患者)和教育程度高亚组(48 名对照者和 28 名前驱 AD 患者)。首先比较了患者与对照组教育程度匹配组之间的脑代谢。然后,在两个方向上比较高教育水平和低教育水平的前驱 AD 患者的代谢,以确定与教育程度相关的高代谢抑制和补偿区域。显著抑制和补偿的聚类区域进一步作为每个前驱 AD 亚组脑区间相关分析的体积感兴趣区(ROI),以探索代谢相关性。所有分析均采用 SPM8 进行(峰值水平的校正 P<0.001,集群水平校正的 P<0.05 假发现率);年龄、性别、简易精神状态检查评分和中心作为混杂因素)。
结果:与教育程度低的前驱 AD 患者相比,高教育程度的前驱 AD 患者在左侧颞中回和颞下回以及左侧中枕叶表现出更严重的代谢抑制(ROI 抑制)。相反,他们在右侧额中回、额下回和额上回表现出相对的代谢亢进(ROI 补偿)。补偿部位主要对应右侧背外侧前额叶皮质(DLFC),在高教育程度的前驱 AD 患者中与双侧半球的多个皮质区域(额颞叶皮质、海马旁回和楔前叶)表现出广泛的代谢相关性,但在低教育程度的前驱 AD 患者中则没有。为了提供这些代谢相关性是否代表高教育水平对照者的生理网络(神经储备)的保护还是替代网络(神经补偿)的招募,或者是两者的组合的证据,我们还对高教育水平的对照组进行了右侧 DLFC 的代谢相关性分析。右侧 DLFC 的相关性部位与高教育水平前驱 AD 患者的部分重叠,但范围较小。
结论:本研究结果表明,高教育水平的前驱 AD 患者能够更好地应对疾病,这要归功于神经储备,以及招募补偿性神经网络,其中右侧 DLFC 发挥关键作用。