Edinburgh Unit for Forensic Anthropology, School of History, Classics and Archaeology, University of Edinburgh, 4 Teviot Place, Edinburgh EH8 9AG, UK.
Forensic Sci Int. 2013 Jun 10;229(1-3):162.e1-6. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2013.03.032. Epub 2013 Apr 16.
The aim of this study is to investigate the potential use of reconstructed three-dimensional multi-detector computed tomography (3D MDCT) imagery to distinguish between perimortem cranial trauma and postmortem cranial damage. A total of 45 crania were initially examined for the purpose of this study. The postmortem group consists of 14 crania from a Medieval Scottish population while the perimortem group consists of 31 CT scans of perimortem trauma cases from the University Hospital of Heraklion, Crete. Six crania belonging to the perimortem group could not be assessed for the purposes of this study. Each of the remaining 39 crania was examined under the following criteria: preponderant texture, preponderant outline, edge morphology, fracture angle, fracture relationship to path of least resistance, evidence of plastic response and the presence of hinging. As edge morphology could not be determined for any of the crania this criterion was not considered for statistical computations. Statistical analysis demonstrated the five of the six criteria (preponderant texture, preponderant outline, fracture relationship to least resistance path, plastic response and the presence of hinging) subjected to statistical analysis bore statistical significance in distinguishing between perimortem trauma and postmortem damage when using 3D CT images. This study, therefore, demonstrated that the timing of cranial fractures can be determined using 3D CT images and thus can complement and add to existing methods for trauma assessment in both forensic and archaeological settings.
本研究旨在探讨重建三维多探测器 CT(3D MDCT)图像在区分生前颅骨创伤和死后颅骨损伤方面的潜在应用。本研究共检查了 45 个头骨。死后组由来自中世纪苏格兰人群的 14 个头骨组成,生前组由克里特岛伊拉克利翁大学医院的 31 例生前创伤 CT 扫描组成。生前组的 6 个头骨由于某种原因无法进行评估。对其余 39 个头骨分别按照以下标准进行检查:主要纹理、主要轮廓、边缘形态、骨折角度、骨折与最小阻力路径的关系、塑性反应证据和铰链的存在。由于任何颅骨都无法确定边缘形态,因此该标准未纳入统计计算。统计分析表明,在使用 3D CT 图像区分生前创伤和死后损伤时,六个标准中的五个(主要纹理、主要轮廓、骨折与最小阻力路径的关系、塑性反应和铰链的存在)具有统计学意义。因此,本研究表明可以使用 3D CT 图像确定颅骨骨折的时间,从而可以补充和增加法医和考古学环境中创伤评估的现有方法。