Sobell Department of Motor Neuroscience, UCL Institute of Neurology, London, UK.
Neurology. 2013 Jun 11;80(24):2242-5. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0b013e318296e977. Epub 2013 May 8.
We compared manual infarct definition, which is time-consuming and open to bias, with an automated abnormal tissue detection method in measuring corticospinal tract-infarct overlap volumes in chronic stroke patients to help predict motor outcome.
Using diffusion tensor imaging and probabilistic tractography, 4 corticospinal tracts from the primary motor cortex, dorsal and ventral premotor cortices, and supplementary motor area to the ipsilateral lower pons were reconstructed in 23 healthy controls. Tract-infarct overlap volume of each of the 4 corticospinal tracts was determined by overlapping the patients' lesions onto the control tract templates, using both manually and automatically defined infarcts in 51 patients. Correlations with upper limb motor impairment were assessed and both methods were directly compared using intraclass correlations (ICC).
Greater impairment was seen in patients with greater corticospinal tract-infarct overlap with either method (rmanual range = 0.32-0.46; rautomated range = 0.42-0.57). Consistency between manual and automated methods was good to excellent for all 4 corticospinal tracts (ICC range = 0.71-0.80).
Our results demonstrate that automated infarct identification performs equally as well as a manual method in quantifying corticospinal tract-infarct overlap following stroke.
我们比较了手动梗死定义,该方法耗时且易受偏差影响,与一种自动异常组织检测方法在测量慢性卒中患者皮质脊髓束-梗死重叠体积方面的差异,以帮助预测运动结局。
使用弥散张量成像和概率性束追踪技术,在 23 名健康对照者中重建了 4 条皮质脊髓束,从初级运动皮层、背侧和腹侧前运动皮层以及辅助运动区到同侧下脑桥。通过将患者的病变与对照束模板重叠,使用手动和自动定义的梗死在 51 名患者中确定每条 4 条皮质脊髓束的梗死重叠体积。评估与上肢运动障碍的相关性,并使用组内相关系数(ICC)直接比较两种方法。
无论哪种方法,皮质脊髓束-梗死重叠体积越大,患者的损伤越严重(rmanual 范围为 0.32-0.46;rautomated 范围为 0.42-0.57)。手动和自动方法在所有 4 条皮质脊髓束上的一致性均为良好至极好(ICC 范围为 0.71-0.80)。
我们的结果表明,在量化卒中后皮质脊髓束-梗死重叠方面,自动梗死识别与手动方法同样有效。