Department of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, Drexel University College of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2012 Dec;41(6):419-25.
There is no standardized curriculum for laryngology within otolaryngology residency programs despite the fact that laryngology is a significant portion of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada examination. Our objective was to evaluate trainee perceptions of laryngology within otolaryngology residency programs.
Cross-sectional survey.
Canadian otolaryngology residency programs.
A Web-based, anonymous survey was conducted among otolaryngology residents. The survey was based on Royal College learning objectives for laryngology. The survey was administered using Dillman's Total Design Method and distributed in English and French.
Sixty-four of 150 (42.6%) residents responded to the survey (55.6% male; mean age 29.3 years). About half of the respondents agreed or strongly agreed that the amount of didactic and clinical laryngology instruction was adequate. About 41.0% agreed or strongly agreed that the amount of operative laryngology instruction was adequate. Cited areas for improvement included injection laryngoplasty, botulinum toxin injection, medialization thyroplasty, care of the professional voice, phonosurgery, and videostroboscopy. Areas of strength included flexible nasopharyngoscopy, laryngeal anatomy, hoarseness, stridor, laryngopharyngeal reflux disease, and vocal cord paralysis. Overall, 40.7% felt somewhat comfortable providing laryngology care. The presence of a laryngology fellowship at the training program, respondent interest in pursuing a fellowship, completion of a laryngology elective, and previous laryngology research did not affect the residency experience. Senior residents are more comfortable with providing laryngology care than juniors.
Several areas of strengths and areas for improvement in laryngology appear to exist within otolaryngology residency programs as perceived by current trainees.
尽管喉科学是加拿大皇家内外科学院考试的重要组成部分,但耳鼻喉科学住院医师培训计划中并没有喉科学的标准化课程。我们的目的是评估住院医师对耳鼻喉科学住院医师培训计划中喉科学的看法。
横断面调查。
加拿大耳鼻喉科学住院医师培训计划。
对耳鼻喉科住院医师进行了基于网络的匿名调查。该调查基于皇家学院的喉科学学习目标。该调查使用 Dillman 的总设计方法进行管理,并以英语和法语两种语言进行分发。
在 150 名住院医师中,有 64 名(42.6%)对调查做出了回应(55.6%为男性;平均年龄 29.3 岁)。约一半的受访者同意或强烈同意理论和临床喉科学教学的数量充足。约 41.0%的人同意或强烈同意手术喉科学教学的数量充足。提出需要改进的领域包括注射性喉成形术、肉毒毒素注射、内侧化甲状软骨成形术、专业嗓音护理、嗓音外科和频闪喉镜检查。优势领域包括灵活的鼻咽镜检查、喉解剖、声音嘶哑、喘鸣、喉咽反流病和声带瘫痪。总体而言,40.7%的人对提供喉科护理感到有些舒适。培训计划中存在喉科学奖学金、受访者对从事奖学金的兴趣、完成喉科学选修课程以及之前的喉科学研究并不会影响住院医师的经历。高年住院医师比低年住院医师更能熟练地提供喉科护理。
目前的住院医师认为,耳鼻喉科学住院医师培训计划中似乎存在一些喉科学的优势和需要改进的领域。