Nickerson A, Bhuta P, Orton G, Alvin B
J Dent Hyg. 1990 Feb;64(2):69-73.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of dental office sterilizers as measured by their ability to kill bacterial spores present on biological indicator strips. The biological indicators used in this study contained two different spores, Bacillus stearothermophilus and Bacillus subtilis (Spordi, AMSCO/Medical Products). Ten spore test strips were sent to 87 dental offices; 51 sterilizers were tested. Office personnel were instructed to place four strips in the center of a normal sterilization load and process the load. The procedure was repeated on a second day. The processed strips, along with two unprocessed control strips, were returned by mail for laboratory culturing. The results indicated the overall failure rate (positive test) of sterlizers tested for both days was 51% at the culturing temperature of 37 degrees C and 33.3% at 55 degrees C. McNemar's test indicated a significant difference (p less than .03) in sterilization failures associated with the type and number of microorganisms present on the test strips. This study also showed that the more times a sterilizer was tested, the more likely a failure would occur. Overall, an alarming number of sterilizers (64.7%) were not effective in killing all the spores present on the indicator strips. When office personnel were given information for improving sterilizer performance, there was a noticeable reduction in sterilization failures following retesting.
本研究的目的是通过牙科诊所消毒器杀灭生物指示剂条上存在的细菌孢子的能力来评估其有效性。本研究中使用的生物指示剂包含两种不同的孢子,嗜热脂肪芽孢杆菌和枯草芽孢杆菌(Spordi,AMSCO/医疗产品)。向87家牙科诊所发送了10条孢子测试条;对51台消毒器进行了测试。指导诊所工作人员将四条测试条放在正常消毒负载的中心并对负载进行处理。第二天重复该程序。处理过的测试条以及两条未处理的对照测试条通过邮件寄回实验室进行培养。结果表明,在37摄氏度的培养温度下,两天测试的消毒器总体故障率(测试呈阳性)为51%,在55摄氏度时为33.3%。McNemar检验表明,与测试条上存在的微生物类型和数量相关的消毒失败存在显著差异(p小于0.03)。本研究还表明,消毒器测试的次数越多,发生故障的可能性就越大。总体而言,数量惊人的消毒器(64.7%)无法有效杀灭指示剂条上存在的所有孢子。当向诊所工作人员提供有关提高消毒器性能的信息时,重新测试后消毒失败的情况明显减少。