Walker P G T, Jost C, Ghani A C, Cauchemez S, Bett B, Azhar M, Murahman J, Widiastuti T, Daju D, Mariner J
MRC Centre for Outbreak Analysis & Modelling, Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Transbound Emerg Dis. 2015 Apr;62(2):200-8. doi: 10.1111/tbed.12108. Epub 2013 Jun 4.
The spread of H5N1 avian influenza continues to pose an economic burden and a public health risk worldwide. Despite this, estimates of the transmissibility of infection exist in only a handful of settings and vary considerably. Using final size methods and flock-level infection data from a field trial of mass vaccination, we obtained the first estimates of the transmissibility of infection between and within flocks in Indonesia. We also found that outbreaks in areas designated as vaccination zones were less transmissible than in non-vaccination zones. However, this reduction is only comparable with a limited degree of protective vaccination coverage. Quantifying the overall effect of vaccination in these zones remains challenging. However, this result would appear to imply that, although the interventions applied in vaccination zones were not sufficient to completely prevent transmission in all areas, when outbreaks occur, they are less transmissible than those in areas where vaccination was not applied. This could be either a direct or an indirect effect of vaccination. Given the dynamism of small-scale poultry production in Indonesia, more regular vaccination may be required to ensure that infection is fully controlled in vaccination zones.
H5N1禽流感的传播继续在全球范围内造成经济负担和公共卫生风险。尽管如此,关于感染传播性的估计仅在少数情况下存在,且差异很大。利用大规模疫苗接种现场试验的最终规模方法和鸡群水平的感染数据,我们首次获得了印度尼西亚鸡群之间和鸡群内部感染传播性的估计值。我们还发现,指定为疫苗接种区的地区疫情传播性低于非疫苗接种区。然而,这种降低仅与有限程度的保护性疫苗接种覆盖率相当。量化这些区域疫苗接种的总体效果仍然具有挑战性。然而,这一结果似乎意味着,尽管在疫苗接种区采取的干预措施不足以完全防止所有地区的传播,但疫情发生时,其传播性低于未接种疫苗的地区。这可能是疫苗接种的直接或间接效果。鉴于印度尼西亚小规模家禽生产的动态性,可能需要更定期的疫苗接种,以确保在疫苗接种区完全控制感染。