Osti Leonardo, Soldati Francesco, Cheli Andrea, Pari Carlotta, Massari Leo, Maffulli Nicola
Unit of Arthroscopy and Sports Medicine, Hesperia Hospital, Modena, Italy.
Muscles Ligaments Tendons J. 2013 Jan 21;2(4):258-66. Print 2012 Oct.
Type II lesions are common lesions encountered in overhead athletes with controversies arising in term of timing for treatment, surgical approach, rehabilitation and functional results. The aim of our study was to evaluate the outcomes of arthroscopic repair of type II SLAP tears in overhead athletes, focusing on the time elapsed from diagnosis and treatment, time needed to return to sport, rate of return to sport and to previous level of performance, providing an overview concerning evidence for the effectiveness of different surgical approaches to type II SLAP tears in overhead athletes. A internet search on peer reviewed Journal from 1990, first descriprion of this pathology, to 2012, have been conducted evaluating the outcomes for both isolated Slap II tear overhead athletes and those who presented associated lesions treated. The results have been analyzed according to the scale reported focusing on return to sport and level of activity. Apart from a single study, non prospective level I and II studies were detected. Return to play at the same level ranged form 22% to 94% with different range of technique utilized with the majority of the authors recommending the fixation of these lesions but biceps tenodesis can lead to higher satisfaction racte when directly compated to the anchor fixation. Associated pathologies such as partial or full tickness rotator cuff tear did not clearly affect the outcomes and complications rate. There is no consensus regarding timing and treatment for type II SLAP, especially in overhead athletes who need to regain a high level of performance.
II型损伤是上肢运动员中常见的损伤,在治疗时机、手术方式、康复及功能结果方面存在争议。我们研究的目的是评估上肢运动员II型肩胛盂上唇前上部分(SLAP)撕裂的关节镜修复结果,重点关注从诊断到治疗的时间、恢复运动所需时间、恢复运动率以及恢复到之前运动水平的情况,概述不同手术方式治疗上肢运动员II型SLAP撕裂有效性的证据。对1990年(该病理首次描述)至2012年的同行评审期刊进行了网络搜索,评估了孤立的II型SLAP撕裂上肢运动员以及伴有相关损伤接受治疗者的结果。根据所报告的量表对结果进行了分析,重点是恢复运动和活动水平。除了一项研究外,未发现前瞻性I级和II级研究。使用不同技术,恢复到同一水平运动的比例在22%至94%之间,大多数作者推荐对这些损伤进行固定,但与锚钉固定直接比较时,肱二头肌固定术可导致更高的满意度。部分或全层肩袖撕裂等相关病变并未明显影响结果和并发症发生率。对于II型SLAP的治疗时机和治疗方法尚无共识,尤其是在上肢运动员中,他们需要恢复到高水平运动表现。