University of Warwick, UK.
Health (London). 2014 Mar;18(2):146-62. doi: 10.1177/1363459313488004. Epub 2013 Jun 5.
This article, based on qualitative research with working-class men, explores men's perceptions and experiences regarding gender differences in health. It demonstrates how men put forward a range of behavioural/cultural, materialist/structural and psychosocial factors, which were believed to differently impact men's health compared to women. A common theme underpinning their explanations was the ways in which men and women were located within two distinct gender categories. These characterisations were used to explain why health-damaging beliefs and behaviours were more prevalent among men and also why men were better suited for certain kinds of jobs, albeit with potential costs to their health. Men also believed that women were protected from the damaging physical and emotional impact of manual employment because of their primary role within the home and because they were less emotionally robust, which required men to shield women from the stresses they experienced. However, men's emotional withdrawal can also be viewed as another example of how men use whatever resources are available to achieve and maintain dominance over women. Finally, the article demonstrates how a gender- and class-based approach can capture the impact of men's health-related practices alongside the broader cultural and structural influences on men's health.
本文基于对工人阶级男性的定性研究,探讨了男性对健康方面性别差异的看法和体验。研究表明,男性提出了一系列行为/文化、物质/结构和心理社会因素,这些因素被认为对男性健康的影响与女性不同。贯穿他们解释的一个共同主题是男性和女性在两个不同性别类别中的定位方式。这些特征被用来解释为什么对健康有害的信念和行为在男性中更为普遍,以及为什么男性更适合某些类型的工作,尽管这可能对他们的健康造成潜在的影响。男性还认为,由于女性在家中的主要角色,以及因为她们的情绪不够坚强,女性不会受到体力和情感劳动的破坏性影响,这使男性有责任保护女性免受她们所经历的压力。然而,男性的情感抽离也可以被视为另一个例子,说明男性如何利用一切可用的资源来实现和维持对女性的支配地位。最后,本文展示了一种基于性别和阶级的方法如何既能捕捉男性与健康相关的行为的影响,又能捕捉更广泛的文化和结构因素对男性健康的影响。