Lukas Sarah, Krinzinger Helga, Koch Iring, Willmes Klaus
a Department of Psychology , RWTH Aachen University , Aachen , Germany.
Q J Exp Psychol (Hove). 2014 Feb;67(2):260-70. doi: 10.1080/17470218.2013.802002. Epub 2013 Jun 8.
Cohen Kadosh found that Hebrew number words and Arabic digits elicited different distance effects. The numerical distance effect (i.e., faster reaction times and smaller error rates for numbers with larger distance to a standard number, e.g., 5) was smaller for number words than for digits. The author suggested that the result indicated a notation-dependent (i.e., nonabstract) numerical representation. Alternatively, however, it is possible that the distance effect was decreased by perceptual features of the Hebrew number words used as stimuli. To test this hypothesis, we replicated the study of Cohen Kadosh, but with English and Turkish number words compared to Arabic digits. The perceptual features of Turkish number words lead to the hypothesis that the opposite effect should be present: an increased distance effect for number words compared to Arabic digits. On the other hand, English number words show features similar to those of Hebrew number words, thus leading to the expectation of a decreased distance effect for them. Our results confirmed our hypotheses. We conclude that the distance effect can be influenced also by perceptual features in addition to the impact of numerical representations.
科恩·卡多什发现,希伯来数字词和阿拉伯数字会引发不同的距离效应。数值距离效应(即对于与标准数字(如5)距离较大的数字,反应时间更快且错误率更低)在数字词中比在数字中更小。作者认为,该结果表明了一种依赖符号表示(即非抽象)的数值表征。然而,另一种可能是,作为刺激物的希伯来数字词的感知特征降低了距离效应。为了验证这一假设,我们重复了科恩·卡多什的研究,但将英语和土耳其语数字词与阿拉伯数字进行了比较。土耳其语数字词的感知特征引发了这样一种假设,即应该会出现相反的效应:与阿拉伯数字相比,数字词的距离效应会增加。另一方面,英语数字词呈现出与希伯来数字词相似的特征,因此预计它们的距离效应会降低。我们的结果证实了我们的假设。我们得出结论,除了数值表征的影响外,距离效应还会受到感知特征的影响。