University College London Institute of Child Health, UK.
Neuroimage. 2013 Nov 15;82:595-604. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.06.003. Epub 2013 Jun 12.
There is increasing interest in applying connectivity analysis to brain measures (Rubinov and Sporns, 2010), but most studies have relied on fMRI, which substantially limits the participant groups and numbers that can be studied. High-density EEG recordings offer a comparatively inexpensive easy-to-use alternative, but require channel-level connectivity analysis which currently lacks a common analytic framework and is very limited in spatial resolution. To address this problem, we have developed a new technique for studies of network development that overcomes the spatial constraint and obtains functional networks of cortical areas by using EEG source reconstruction with age-matched average MRI templates (He et al., 1999). In contrast to previously reported channel-level analysis, this approach provides information about the cortical areas most likely to be involved in the network as well as their functional relationship (Babiloni et al., 2005; De Vico Fallani et al., 2007). In this study, we applied source reconstruction with age-matched templates to task-free high-density EEG recordings in typically-developing children between 2 and 6 years of age (O'Reilly, 2012). Graph theory was then applied to the association strengths of 68 cortical regions of interest based on the Desikan-Killiany atlas. We found linear increases of mean node degree, mean clustering coefficient and maximum betweenness centrality between 2 years and 6 years of age. Characteristic path length was negatively correlated with age. The correlation of the network measures with age indicates network development towards more closely integrated networks similar to reports from other imaging modalities (Fair et al., 2008; Power et al., 2010). We also applied eigenvalue decomposition to obtain functional modules (Clayden et al., 2013). Connection strength within these modules did not change with age, and the modules resembled hub networks previously described for MRI (Hagmann et al., 2010; Power et al., 2010). The high temporal resolution of EEG additionally allowed us to distinguish between frequency bands potentially reflecting dynamic coupling between different neural oscillators. Generally, network parameters were similar for networks based on different frequency bands, but frequency band did emerge as a significant factor for clustering coefficient and characteristic path length. In conclusion, the current analysis shows that source reconstruction of high-density EEG recordings with appropriate head models offers a valuable tool for estimating network parameters in studies of brain development. The findings replicate the pattern of closer functional integration over development described for other imaging modalities (Fair et al., 2008; Power et al., 2010).
人们越来越感兴趣于将连接分析应用于脑测量(Rubinov 和 Sporns,2010),但大多数研究都依赖于 fMRI,这极大地限制了可研究的参与者群体和数量。高密度 EEG 记录提供了一种相对便宜且易于使用的替代方法,但需要进行通道级连接分析,而目前这种方法缺乏通用的分析框架,空间分辨率也非常有限。为了解决这个问题,我们开发了一种新的技术,用于研究网络发展,该技术克服了空间约束,并通过使用年龄匹配的平均 MRI 模板进行 EEG 源重建来获得皮质区域的功能网络(He 等人,1999 年)。与之前报道的通道级分析相比,这种方法提供了有关最有可能参与网络的皮质区域及其功能关系的信息(Babiloni 等人,2005 年;De Vico Fallani 等人,2007 年)。在这项研究中,我们将年龄匹配模板的源重建应用于 2 至 6 岁正常发育儿童的无任务高密度 EEG 记录(O'Reilly,2012)。然后,我们根据 Desikan-Killiany 图谱将图论应用于 68 个皮质感兴趣区域的关联强度。我们发现,2 至 6 岁之间,平均节点度、平均聚类系数和最大中间中心度呈线性增加。特征路径长度与年龄呈负相关。网络测量值与年龄的相关性表明,网络朝着更加紧密集成的网络发展,这与其他成像模式的报告相似(Fair 等人,2008 年;Power 等人,2010 年)。我们还应用特征值分解来获得功能模块(Clayden 等人,2013 年)。这些模块内的连接强度随年龄变化而不变,并且这些模块类似于先前为 MRI 描述的枢纽网络(Hagmann 等人,2010 年;Power 等人,2010 年)。EEG 的高时间分辨率还使我们能够区分可能反映不同神经振荡器之间动态耦合的频带。通常,基于不同频带的网络的网络参数相似,但频带确实成为聚类系数和特征路径长度的重要因素。总之,目前的分析表明,使用适当的头部模型对高密度 EEG 记录进行源重建为估计脑发育研究中的网络参数提供了有价值的工具。研究结果复制了其他成像模式描述的随着发育而更加紧密的功能整合模式(Fair 等人,2008 年;Power 等人,2010 年)。