Koopmans Laura, Wilson Trish, Cacciatore Joanne, Flenady Vicki
MaterMedical Research Institute,MaterHealth Services,Woolloongabba, Australia.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013 Jun 19;2013(6):CD000452. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000452.pub3.
Provision of an empathetic, sensitive, caring environment and strategies to support mothers, fathers and their families experiencing perinatal death are now an accepted part of maternity services in many countries. Interventions such as psychological support or counselling, or both, have been suggested to improve outcomes for parents and families after perinatal death.
To assess the effect of any form of intervention (i.e. medical, nursing, midwifery, social work, psychology, counselling or community-based) on parents and families who experience perinatal death.
We searched the Cochrane Pregnancy and Childbirth Group's Trials Register (28 January 2013) and article bibliographies.
Randomised trials of any form of support aimed at encouraging acceptance of loss, bereavement counselling, or specialised psychotherapy or counselling for mothers, fathers and families experiencing perinatal death.
Two review authors independently assessed eligibility of trials.
No trials were included.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: Primary healthcare interventions and a strong family and social support network are invaluable to parents and families around the time a baby dies. However, due to the lack of high-quality randomised trials conducted in this area, the true benefits of currently existing interventions aimed at providing support for mothers, fathers and families experiencing perinatal death is unclear. Further, the currently available evidence around the potential detrimental effects of some interventions (e.g. seeing and holding a deceased baby) remains inconclusive at this point in time. However, some well-designed descriptive studies have shown that, under the right circumstances and guided by compassionate, sensitive, experienced staff, parents' experiences of seeing and holding their deceased baby is often very positive. The sensitive nature of this topic and small sample sizes, make it difficult to develop rigorous clinical trials. Hence, other research designs may further inform practice in this area. Where justified, methodologically rigorous trials are needed. However, methodologically rigorous trials should be considered comparing different approaches to support.
在许多国家,营造一个富有同理心、体贴入微、关怀备至的环境以及提供支持经历围产期死亡的母亲、父亲及其家庭的策略,如今已成为产科服务公认的一部分。有人建议采取心理支持或咨询,或两者兼施的干预措施,以改善围产期死亡后父母及其家庭的结局。
评估任何形式的干预措施(即医疗、护理、助产、社会工作、心理学、咨询或社区干预)对经历围产期死亡的父母及其家庭的影响。
我们检索了Cochrane妊娠与分娩组试验注册库(2013年1月28日)及文章参考文献。
针对经历围产期死亡的母亲、父亲及其家庭,旨在鼓励接受丧亲之痛、进行丧亲辅导或提供专门心理治疗或咨询的任何形式支持的随机试验。
两位综述作者独立评估试验的合格性。
未纳入任何试验。
在婴儿死亡前后,初级医疗保健干预措施以及强大的家庭和社会支持网络对父母及其家庭极为重要。然而,由于该领域缺乏高质量的随机试验,目前旨在为经历围产期死亡的母亲、父亲及其家庭提供支持的现有干预措施的真正益处尚不清楚。此外,目前关于某些干预措施(如查看和抱抱已故婴儿)潜在有害影响的现有证据在此时仍无定论。然而,一些精心设计的描述性研究表明,在合适的情况下,在富有同情心、体贴入微且经验丰富的工作人员的指导下,父母查看和抱抱已故婴儿的经历通常非常积极。该主题的敏感性以及样本量较小,使得开展严格的临床试验变得困难。因此,其他研究设计可能会为该领域的实践提供更多信息。在合理的情况下,需要进行方法严谨的试验。然而,应考虑进行方法严谨的试验来比较不同的支持方法。