Frankel Grace Elisabeth Charlotte, Austin Zubin
Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario.
Can Pharm J (Ott). 2013 May;146(3):155-61. doi: 10.1177/1715163513487309.
Despite the changing role of the pharmacist in patient-centred practice, pharmacists anecdotally reported little confidence in their clinical decision-making skills and do not feel responsible for their patients. Observational findings have suggested these trends within the profession, but there is a paucity of evidence to explain why. We conducted an exploratory study with an objective to identify reasons for the lack of responsibility and/or confidence in various pharmacy practice settings.
Pharmacist interviews were conducted via written response, face-to-face or telephone. Seven questions were asked on the topic of responsibility and confidence as it applies to pharmacy practice and how pharmacists think these themes differ in medicine. Interview transcripts were analyzed and divided by common theme. Quotations to support these themes are presented.
Twenty-nine pharmacists were asked to participate, and 18 responded (62% response rate). From these interviews, 6 themes were identified as barriers to confidence and responsibility: hierarchy of the medical system, role definitions, evolution of responsibility, ownership of decisions for confidence building, quality and consequences of mentorship and personality traits upon admission.
We identified 6 potential barriers to the development of pharmacists' self-confidence and responsibility. These findings have practical applicability for educational research, future curriculum changes, experiential learning structure and pharmacy practice. Due to bias and the limitations of this form of exploratory research and small sample size, evidence should be interpreted cautiously.
Pharmacists feel neither responsible nor confident for their clinical decisions due to social, educational, experiential and personal reasons. Can Pharm J 2013;146:155-161.
尽管药剂师在以患者为中心的实践中的角色不断变化,但据药剂师们反映,他们对自己的临床决策技能信心不足,且感觉对患者不负有责任。观察结果表明了该行业内的这些趋势,但缺乏证据来解释其原因。我们开展了一项探索性研究,旨在确定在各种药学实践环境中缺乏责任感和/或信心的原因。
通过书面回复、面对面或电话方式对药剂师进行访谈。围绕适用于药学实践的责任和信心这一主题,以及药剂师认为这些主题在医学领域有何不同,提出了七个问题。对访谈记录进行分析,并按共同主题进行分类。给出了支持这些主题的引述。
邀请了29名药剂师参与,18人做出回应(回应率为62%)。从这些访谈中,确定了六个被视为信心和责任障碍的主题:医疗系统的层级结构、角色定义、责任的演变、建立信心的决策归属、指导的质量和影响以及入职时的个性特征。
我们确定了药剂师自信心和责任感发展的六个潜在障碍。这些发现对教育研究、未来课程改革、实践学习结构和药学实践具有实际应用价值。由于这种探索性研究形式存在偏见和局限性,且样本量较小,证据应谨慎解读。
由于社会、教育、实践和个人原因,药剂师对自己的临床决策既无责任感也缺乏信心。《加拿大药剂师杂志》2013年;146:155 - 161。