Ghesquiere Angela, Shear M Katherine, Duan Naihua
Weill Cornell Medical College, White Plains, NY, USA.
J Prim Care Community Health. 2013 Oct;4(4):256-64. doi: 10.1177/2150131913481231. Epub 2013 Mar 11.
Bereavement is common among older adults and may result in major depression or complicated grief (CG). Little is known about the effectiveness of physician care for these conditions. We examined whether, among older adults with CG and/or major depression, using physician support was associated with reductions in grief, depression, or anxiety severity. Outcomes were compared to group and religious support. We analyzed data from the Changing Lives of Older Couples (CLOC) Study, a prospective cohort study of married couples in the Detroit area. Spousal death was tracked over 5 years, and follow-up interviews conducted with widowed participants at 6 months (wave 1) and 18 months (wave 2) post loss. Analyses were limited to those with CG or depression with support-seeking data (weighted n = 89). Yes/no items asked whether participants had seen each provider for help with grief up until wave 1. A 19-item grief severity measure was developed by CLOC researchers. The 20-item Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression scale measured depression severity. The Symptom Checklist 90-Revised assessed anxiety severity. Regressions indicated that seeking support from a family doctor at wave 1 was not associated with changes in anxiety, depression, or grief severity at wave 2 (P > .05). However, support group use was associated with reductions in grief severity (β = -8.46, P < .05), and religious leader support-seeking associated with reductions in depression severity (β = -10.12, P < .01). Findings imply that physician care for grief may not be effective, and support group referral may be helpful. Physicians may benefit from training in recognizing and appropriate referring for bereavement-related distress.
丧亲之痛在老年人中很常见,可能导致重度抑郁症或复杂性哀伤(CG)。对于医生针对这些情况的治疗效果,我们知之甚少。我们研究了在患有CG和/或重度抑郁症的老年人中,寻求医生支持是否与哀伤、抑郁或焦虑严重程度的降低有关。将这些结果与团体支持和宗教支持进行了比较。我们分析了来自“老年夫妻生活变化”(CLOC)研究的数据,这是一项对底特律地区已婚夫妇进行的前瞻性队列研究。对配偶死亡情况进行了5年的跟踪,并在丧偶参与者失去配偶后的6个月(第1波)和18个月(第2波)进行了随访访谈。分析仅限于那些有寻求支持数据的CG或抑郁症患者(加权n = 89)。是/否项目询问参与者在第1波之前是否曾向每位提供者寻求过哀伤方面的帮助。CLOC研究人员制定了一项包含19个项目的哀伤严重程度测量方法。使用包含20个项目的流行病学研究中心抑郁量表来测量抑郁严重程度。症状自评量表90修订版评估焦虑严重程度。回归分析表明,在第1波向家庭医生寻求支持与第2波焦虑、抑郁或哀伤严重程度的变化无关(P > .05)。然而,使用支持小组与哀伤严重程度的降低有关(β = -8.46,P < .05),而寻求宗教领袖支持与抑郁严重程度的降低有关(β = -10.12,P < .01)。研究结果表明,医生对哀伤的治疗可能无效,而转介至支持小组可能会有所帮助。医生可能会从识别和适当转介与丧亲相关困扰的培训中受益。