Saleh Abubakir M, Al-Tawawil Namir G, Shabila Nazar P, Al-Hadithi Tariq S
Department of Community Medicine, College of Medicine, Hawler Medical University , Erbil, Iraq .
J Clin Diagn Res. 2013 May;7(5):883-7. doi: 10.7860/JCDR/2013/5455.2966. Epub 2013 Mar 21.
Although the medical schools in Iraq recently started to increasingly use the small group teaching approach, only little is known about the students' perceptions toward this approach. Therefore, the aim of this study was to assess small group teaching as a method of teaching at Hawler College of Medicine, from the students' perspectives.
This study was a qualitative study which was based on six focus group discussions which involved a sample of students from the three last years at the Hawler College of Medicine. A topic guide was used to lead the discussions and it covered questions on the positive aspects and the problems of small group teaching in the college, in addition to recommendations for its improvement. The qualitative data analysis involved a content analysis, followed by a thematic analysis.
The participants were generally happy with the application of the small group teaching approach and they recognized many positive aspects which were related to this experience, which included, increasing the focus on the study subjects, enhancing the student-teacher interaction, building a better student-teacher relationship, encouraging the students' attendance, providing a better opportunity to apply a student-centered learning, enhancing a more efficient use of time and assisting in a better understanding of the subjects. The main problems which were faced, included a poor infrastructure and teaching facilities, problems which were related to examinations and the mark distribution, an improper syllabus preparation and problems which were related to the teachers' commitments and performances. The main suggestions which were put forth to improve this system, included, changing the assessment system with the focus more on the end of the course assessment, the students' involvement in the curriculum design, improving the infrastructure and teaching facilities and a better organization and management of the system.
The concept of the small group teaching approach was well received by the students and many positive aspects of this approach have been highlighted. However, this experience witnessed many problems and faced different challenges that need better preparation, organization of the resources and the orientation of students and teachers, for insuring its success.
尽管伊拉克的医学院校最近开始越来越多地采用小组教学法,但对于学生对这种教学法的看法却知之甚少。因此,本研究的目的是从学生的角度评估小组教学法在哈勒尔医学院的教学效果。
本研究是一项定性研究,基于六次焦点小组讨论,参与者为哈勒尔医学院最后三年的学生样本。使用了一个主题指南来引导讨论,其中涵盖了关于该学院小组教学的积极方面和问题,以及改进建议。定性数据分析包括内容分析,随后进行主题分析。
参与者总体上对小组教学法的应用感到满意,他们认识到了与这种经历相关的许多积极方面,包括增强对学习科目的关注、加强师生互动、建立更好的师生关系、鼓励学生出勤、提供更好的以学生为中心的学习机会、提高时间利用效率以及有助于更好地理解学科。面临的主要问题包括基础设施和教学设施差、与考试和分数分配有关的问题、教学大纲准备不当以及与教师的投入和表现有关的问题。为改进该系统提出的主要建议包括,改变评估系统,更多地关注课程结束时的评估、让学生参与课程设计、改善基础设施和教学设施以及更好地组织和管理该系统。
小组教学法的理念受到了学生的好评,该方法的许多积极方面也得到了凸显。然而,这种教学经历也遇到了许多问题并面临不同挑战,需要更好地准备、资源组织以及学生和教师的引导,以确保其成功。