Department of Respiratory Medicine, Hospices Civils de Lyon, Lyon Sud University Hospital, Pierre Bénite Cedex, France.
Clin Lung Cancer. 2013 Sep;14(5):574-80. doi: 10.1016/j.cllc.2013.05.003. Epub 2013 Jul 3.
Screening for lung cancer by low-dose computed tomography scan (LDCTS) has been demonstrated to reduce lung cancer-specific and overall mortality rates in high-risk individuals. From trial to clinical practice, it is crucial to obtain an accurate level of knowledge of the physicians who will recruit patients for a screening program. The actual current practice and knowledge of practitioners are unknown. This could be critical to develop dedicated continuous medical education programs.
Three groups of French physicians--pulmonologists (PUs), thoracic oncologists (TOs), and general practitioners (GPs)--were surveyed through a dedicated questionnaire on lung cancer screening.
A total of 242 physicians answered the questionnaire; 81% of TOs knew that LDCTS showed efficacy for screening lung cancer compared with 52% of PUs and 18% of GPs (P < .0001). Approximately one third of physicians recommended lung cancer screening in daily practice at the time of the survey, including 53% of PUs, 34% of TOs, and 20% of GPs (P < .001). However, 94% of GPs, 44% of PUs, and 33% of TOs used inappropriate tests, mainly chest radiography. Most GPs proposed screening for all smokers, whereas PUs and TOs reserved screening for heavy smokers (P = .040). Most PUs and TOs recommended annual LDCTS (76%), whereas the majority of GPs sent patients for screening tests every 3 to 5 years (93%; P < .0001).
These results highlight the interest of physicians for lung cancer screening; meanwhile, our data stress the need for appropriate medical education and recommendations based on available evidence.
低剂量计算机断层扫描(LDCTS)筛查肺癌已被证明可降低高危人群的肺癌特异性和总体死亡率。从试验到临床实践,了解将为筛查计划招募患者的医生的准确知识水平至关重要。目前尚不清楚实际从业者的实践和知识水平。这对于制定专门的持续医学教育计划可能至关重要。
通过专门的肺癌筛查问卷对三组法国医生-肺科医生(PUs)、胸部肿瘤学家(TOs)和全科医生(GPs)进行了调查。
共有 242 名医生回答了问卷;81%的 TOs 知道 LDCTS 显示对筛查肺癌有效,而 52%的 PUs 和 18%的 GPs 知道(P <.0001)。大约三分之一的医生在调查时建议在日常实践中进行肺癌筛查,包括 53%的 PUs、34%的 TOs 和 20%的 GPs(P <.001)。然而,94%的 GPs、44%的 PUs 和 33%的 TOs 使用了不合适的检查,主要是胸部 X 光检查。大多数 GPs 建议对所有吸烟者进行筛查,而 PUs 和 TOs 则将筛查保留给重度吸烟者(P =.040)。大多数 PUs 和 TOs 建议每年进行 LDCTS(76%),而大多数 GPs 则建议每 3 至 5 年进行一次筛查测试(93%;P <.0001)。
这些结果强调了医生对肺癌筛查的兴趣;同时,我们的数据强调了根据现有证据进行适当医学教育和建议的必要性。