Ganesan T S, Wrigley P F, Murray P A, Stansfeld A G, d'Ardenne A J, Arnott S, Jones A, Shand W S, Malpas J S, Lister T A
ICRF Department of Medical Oncology, St Bartholomew's Hospital, West Smithfield, Little Britain, London, UK.
Br J Cancer. 1990 Aug;62(2):314-8. doi: 10.1038/bjc.1990.285.
One hundred and one consecutive patients with newly diagnosed stage I Hodgkin's disease (HD) received treatment at St Bartholomew's Hospital, between 1968 and 1987, with a median follow-up of 12 years. Eleven patients have been excluded from detailed analysis because they either received involved field radiotherapy (RT) or radiotherapy with chemotherapy or were lost to follow-up. Actuarial analysis predicts 78% to be alive and without relapse of Hodgkin's disease at 15 years. Ninety evaluable patients (clinical stage (CS) 24; pathological stage (PS) 66) received either mantle or inverted 'Y' RT and form the basis of this analysis. The median age was 33 years (63 men, 27 women). Histology at presentation was nodular sclerosing (39), lymphocytic predominant (27) or mixed cellularity (24). The presenting site was neck (78), axilla (6) groin (4) and mediastinum (2). Complete remission was achieved in all evaluable patients, the actuarial proportion in remission being 75% at 15 years. Factors predictive of a prolonged remission were pathological staging versus clinical staging (P = 0.02) and lymph node size less than 3 cm (P = 0.04). Actuarial overall survival in these 90 patients was 75% at 15 years and none of the above factors correlated with survival. Relapse of HD has occurred in 18 patients (5 within RT field, 10 without and 3 in both). Second remission was achieved in 15/18. The actuarial rate of second remission and survival was 40% at 10 years. Sixteen patients have died, 7 of Hodgkin's disease, 7 of unrelated causes and 2 of second malignancy. A further 3 patients who developed second malignancy are still alive. At 15 years the actuarial mortality related to HD was 12%. These results confirm the importance of long follow up to assess the efficacy of primary therapy.
1968年至1987年间,101例新诊断为I期霍奇金病(HD)的连续患者在圣巴塞洛缪医院接受了治疗,中位随访时间为12年。11例患者被排除在详细分析之外,因为他们要么接受了受累野放疗(RT),要么接受了放疗联合化疗,要么失访。精算分析预测,15年时78%的患者存活且无霍奇金病复发。90例可评估患者(临床分期(CS)24例;病理分期(PS)66例)接受了斗篷式或倒“Y”形放疗,构成了本分析的基础。中位年龄为33岁(男性63例,女性27例)。初诊时的组织学类型为结节硬化型(39例)、淋巴细胞为主型(27例)或混合细胞型(24例)。初诊部位为颈部(78例)、腋窝(6例)、腹股沟(4例)和纵隔(2例)。所有可评估患者均实现完全缓解,15年时精算缓解率为75%。预测缓解期延长的因素为病理分期与临床分期(P = 0.02)以及淋巴结大小小于3 cm(P = 0.04)。这90例患者15年时的精算总生存率为75%,上述因素均与生存率无关。18例患者发生了HD复发(5例在放疗野内,10例不在放疗野内,3例在放疗野内外均有)。18例中有15例实现了二次缓解。10年时二次缓解和生存的精算率为40%。16例患者死亡,7例死于霍奇金病,7例死于无关原因,2例死于第二原发恶性肿瘤。另外3例发生第二原发恶性肿瘤的患者仍存活。15年时与HD相关的精算死亡率为12%。这些结果证实了长期随访对于评估初始治疗疗效的重要性。