Leibenhaut M H, Hoppe R T, Efron B, Halpern J, Nelsen T, Rosenberg S A
Department of Radiation Oncology, Stanford University Medical Center, CA 94305.
J Clin Oncol. 1989 Jan;7(1):81-91. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1989.7.1.81.
Between July 1968 and July 1986, 915 patients with clinical stage (CS) I and II Hodgkin's disease limited to sites above the diaphragm underwent laparotomy and splenectomy at Stanford University. Fifteen percent were CS I, of whom 76% had cervical/supraclavicular disease, 13% axillary disease, and 9% mediastinal presentations. CS I patients were more likely to be male, were significantly older, and were significantly less likely to have nodular sclerosis (NS) histology than CS II patients. Twenty percent of CS I patients and 30% of CS II patients were pathologically upstaged. No CS I patients were upstaged to pathological stage (PS) IV. Univariate and multivariate analyses of presenting clinical characteristics were performed to predict staging laparotomy findings. CS I women, CS I patients with mediastinal-only disease, and CS I men with either lymphocyte predominance or interfollicular histologies were at low risk for having disease below the diaphragm (5%) or requiring chemotherapy (0%). CS II women who were less than 27 years old and had only two or three sites of disease were also at low risk for upstaging (9%) or requiring chemotherapy (2%). Mixed cellularity histology and male gender were associated with increased risk for subdiaphragmatic disease and require laparotomy; the presence of systemic symptoms was not correlated with laparotomy findings. These results confirm the importance of performing staging laparotomy for the majority of patients who present with supradiaphragmatic Hodgkin's disease if treatment programs are based on the presence and extent of subdiaphragmatic disease. Selected subgroups are at low risk for subdiaphragmatic disease and might be spared laparotomy if they are treated with mantle, paraaortic, and splenic irradiation.
1968年7月至1986年7月期间,915例临床分期(CS)为I期和II期、病变局限于横膈以上部位的霍奇金淋巴瘤患者在斯坦福大学接受了剖腹探查术和脾切除术。15%为CS I期,其中76%有颈部/锁骨上病变,13%有腋窝病变,9%有纵隔表现。与CS II期患者相比,CS I期患者男性居多,年龄显著更大,且结节硬化(NS)组织学类型的可能性显著更小。20%的CS I期患者和30%的CS II期患者病理分期上调。没有CS I期患者上调至病理分期(PS)IV期。对呈现的临床特征进行单因素和多因素分析以预测分期剖腹探查结果。CS I期女性、仅患有纵隔疾病的CS I期患者以及具有淋巴细胞为主型或滤泡间组织学类型的CS I期男性患者,其横膈以下有病变(5%)或需要化疗(0%)的风险较低。年龄小于27岁且仅有两三个病变部位的CS II期女性患者,其分期上调(9%)或需要化疗(2%)的风险也较低。混合细胞性组织学类型和男性性别与横膈以下疾病风险增加相关且需要进行剖腹探查术;全身症状的存在与剖腹探查结果无关。这些结果证实,如果治疗方案基于横膈以下疾病的存在和范围,那么对于大多数表现为横膈上霍奇金淋巴瘤的患者进行分期剖腹探查术很重要。部分亚组患者横膈以下疾病风险较低,如果采用斗篷野、主动脉旁和脾区照射进行治疗,可能无需进行剖腹探查术。