Genetic Counseling Program, Cal State University Northridge, CA, USA.
Contemp Clin Trials. 2013 Sep;36(1):256-62. doi: 10.1016/j.cct.2013.07.006. Epub 2013 Jul 19.
Persons at risk for autosomal dominant neurodegenerative diseases provide the opportunity to efficiently test preventive interventions. Only a minority of such persons, however, choose to undergo revealing genetic testing, presenting a challenge to enrollment. Thirty-four preclinical Latinos (n = 26) and non-Latinos at risk for familial Alzheimer's disease (FAD) unaware of their genetic status were administered a questionnaire exploring their interest in undergoing revealing genetic testing at baseline and in the context of eligibility for four prevention trials of increasing invasiveness. Forty-four percent of subjects expressed a baseline interest in undergoing revealing testing which increased to 85% in order to be eligible for a study of an oral drug "felt to be very safe." If there were a 50% chance of receiving placebo, this number dropped to 62% (p = 0.02). Among those not interested in a study involving a 50% chance of receiving placebo, a range of 5% to 40% chance of receiving placebo was given as acceptable. For more invasive studies, living in the United States (as opposed to Mexico) positively influenced the likelihood of participating. Our data suggest that clinical trial designs in which persons must confront their genetic status prior to enrollment are feasible. Study designs to minimize the likelihood of being placed on placebo or provide the eventual administration of the drug through open-label extensions should be considered.
常染色体显性遗传神经退行性疾病的高危人群为有效测试预防干预措施提供了机会。然而,只有少数高危人群愿意接受基因检测,这对入组造成了挑战。34 名未经基因检测的拉丁裔(n=26)和非拉丁裔家族性阿尔茨海默病(FAD)高危人群接受了一项问卷调查,内容包括他们在基线时以及在符合四项侵袭性递增预防试验条件下对接受基因检测的意愿。44%的受试者表示在基线时对接受基因检测感兴趣,而如果有 50%的机会接受安慰剂,这一比例会上升至 85%(p=0.02)。在那些对接受安慰剂概率为 50%的研究不感兴趣的人群中,有 5%至 40%的概率接受安慰剂被认为是可接受的。对于更具侵袭性的研究,居住在美国(而不是墨西哥)会增加参与的可能性。我们的数据表明,在入组前必须让参与者直面其基因状况的临床试验设计是可行的。应考虑设计研究方案,以尽量减少被置于安慰剂组的可能性,或通过开放标签扩展最终给予药物治疗。