Williams Shawn, Zipp Genevieve P, Cahill Terrence, Parasher Raju K
Department of Health Professions, CUNY York College, Jamaica, NY 11451, USA.
J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2013 Jul-Aug;36(6):376-84. doi: 10.1016/j.jmpt.2013.05.025.
The purpose of this study was to measure the prevalence of burnout among doctors of chiropractic (DCs) in the New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania geographical region and compare these results with burnout data from other health care professions.
This exploratory study applied cross-sectional data collection methods. Using nonprobability convenience sampling, a New York-New Jersey-Pennsylvania chiropractic governance body provided contact information of a randomized sample of licensed DCs from their membership directory. Participants included any DC licensed to practice chiropractic whose primary occupation encompassed the chiropractic profession. The Maslach Burnout Inventory-Human Services Survey (MBI-HSS) and a demographic questionnaire were e-mailed to a randomized sample of licensed DCs.
Of the 772 surveys deployed, 90 returned the survey with usable data. Nearly 40% of the DCs reported a moderate (24%) or high (18%) level of emotional exhaustion, whereas the majority of respondents scored a high (72%) level of personal accomplishment. In total, only 2 participants (2%) met the criteria for high burnout, whereas 42 participants (47%) were low. Statistically significant relationships (P < .001) were found between burnout subscales and the effect of time dedicated to administrative duties, the type of practice setting, the varying chiropractic philosophical perspectives, the public's opinion of chiropractic, and the effect of suffering from a work-related injury. When compared with data from previously published studies using the MBI-HSS for other health professions (ie, medical, nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and dentistry), the values for DCs were significantly lower.
The sample of DCs in this study fared more favorably on all 3 dimensions of burnout. They reported lower emotional exhaustion and depersonalization scores and higher personal accomplishment scores than their medical, nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, and dentistry colleagues who have been evaluated using the MBI-HSS. However, the levels of emotional exhaustion remain a concern for this professional group.
本研究旨在衡量纽约、新泽西和宾夕法尼亚地理区域内整脊疗法医生(DC)的职业倦怠患病率,并将这些结果与其他医疗保健行业的职业倦怠数据进行比较。
本探索性研究采用横断面数据收集方法。通过非概率便利抽样,一个纽约 - 新泽西 - 宾夕法尼亚整脊疗法管理机构从其会员名录中提供了随机抽取的持牌整脊疗法医生的联系信息。参与者包括任何以整脊疗法为主要职业的持牌整脊疗法医生。向随机抽取的持牌整脊疗法医生发送了马氏职业倦怠量表 - 人类服务调查(MBI - HSS)和一份人口统计问卷。
在发放的772份调查问卷中,90份返回了具有可用数据的调查问卷。近40%的整脊疗法医生报告有中度(24%)或高度(18%)的情感耗竭,而大多数受访者个人成就感得分较高(72%)。总体而言,只有2名参与者(2%)符合高度职业倦怠的标准,而42名参与者(47%)为低度职业倦怠。在职业倦怠子量表与用于行政职责的时间影响、执业环境类型、不同的整脊疗法哲学观点、公众对整脊疗法的看法以及与工作相关的受伤影响之间发现了具有统计学意义的关系(P <.001)。与之前使用MBI - HSS对其他医疗行业(即医学、护理、物理治疗、职业治疗和牙科)进行的研究数据相比,整脊疗法医生的数据显著更低。
本研究中的整脊疗法医生样本在职业倦怠的所有三个维度上表现更为良好。与使用MBI - HSS进行评估的医学、护理、物理治疗、职业治疗和牙科同事相比,他们报告的情感耗竭和去个性化得分更低,个人成就感得分更高。然而,情感耗竭水平仍然是这个专业群体的一个关注点。