Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX.
University of Colorado Health Sciences Center, Denver, CO.
Chest. 2013 Nov;144(5):1521-1529. doi: 10.1378/chest.12-3023.
Time to clinical worsening has been proposed as a primary end point in clinical trials of pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH); however, neither standardized nor validated definitions of clinical worsening across PAH trials exist. This study aims to evaluate a proposed definition of clinical worsening within a large prospective, observational registry of patients with PAH with respect to its value as a predictor of proximate (within 1 year) risk for subsequent major events (ie, death, transplantation, or atrial septostomy).
We assessed overall 2-year survival and survival free from major events to determine the relationship between clinical worsening and major events among adults with hemodynamically defined PAH (N = 3,001). Freedom from clinical worsening was defined as freedom from worsening functional class (FC), a ≥ 15% reduction in 6-min walk distance (6MWD), all-cause hospitalization, or the introduction of parenteral prostacyclin analog therapy.
In the 2 years of follow-up, 583 patients died. Four hundred twenty-six died after a documented clinical worsening event, including FC worsening (n = 128), a ≥ 15% reduction in 6MWD (n = 118), all-cause hospitalization (n = 370), or introduction of a prostacyclin analog (n = 91). Patients who experienced clinical worsening had significantly poorer subsequent 1-year survival postworsening than patients who did not worsen (P < .001).
Clinical worsening was highly predictive of subsequent proximate mortality in this analysis from an observational study. These results validate the use of clinical worsening as a meaningful prognostic tool in clinical practice and as a primary end point in clinical trial design.
ClinicalTrials.gov; No.: NCT00370214; URL: www.clinicaltrials.gov.
在肺动脉高压(PAH)的临床试验中,已将临床恶化时间作为主要终点提出;然而,在 PAH 试验中,既没有标准化也没有验证过的临床恶化定义。本研究旨在评估一个针对 PAH 患者的大型前瞻性观察性注册研究中,将恶化定义为预测近期(1 年内)随后主要事件(即死亡、移植或房间隔造口术)风险的价值。
我们评估了整体 2 年生存率和无主要事件生存率,以确定在血流动力学定义的 PAH 成人中,临床恶化与主要事件之间的关系(N = 3001)。无临床恶化定义为无功能恶化(FC)、6 分钟步行距离(6MWD)增加≥15%、全因住院或静脉注射前列环素类似物治疗。
在 2 年的随访中,583 例患者死亡。426 例患者在有记录的临床恶化事件后死亡,包括 FC 恶化(n = 128)、6MWD 增加≥15%(n = 118)、全因住院(n = 370)或使用前列环素类似物(n = 91)。与未恶化的患者相比,经历临床恶化的患者在恶化后 1 年的生存率明显较差(P <.001)。
在这项观察性研究的分析中,临床恶化对随后的近期死亡率具有高度预测性。这些结果验证了临床恶化作为一种有意义的临床实践预后工具和临床试验设计的主要终点的使用。
ClinicalTrials.gov;编号:NCT00370214;网址:www.clinicaltrials.gov。