Houck Jared, Kopietz Courtni M, Shah Bhavin C, Goede Matthew R, McBride Corrigan L, Oleynikov Dmitry
Department of Surgery, Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA.
JSLS. 2013 Apr-Jun;17(2):174-7. doi: 10.4293/108680813X13654754534503.
The introduction of new surgical techniques has made training in laparoscopic procedures a necessity for the practicing surgeon, but acquisition of new surgical skills is a formidable task. This study was conducted to assess the impact of advanced laparoscopic workshops on caseload patterns of practicing surgeons.
After we obtained institutional review board approval, a survey of practicing surgeons who participated in advanced laparoscopic courses was distributed; the results were analyzed for statistical significance. The courses were held at the University of Nebraska Medical Center between January 2002 and December 2010. Questionnaires were mailed, faxed, and e-mailed to surgeons.
Of the 109 surgeons who participated in the advanced laparoscopy courses, 79 received surveys and 30 were excluded from the survey because of their affiliation with the University of Nebraska Medical Center. A total of 47 responses (59%) were received from 41 male and 6 female surgeons. The median response time from completion of the course to completion of the survey was 13.2 months (range, 6.8-19.1 months). The mean age of participating surgeons was 39.2 years (range, 29-51 years). The mean time since residency was 8.4 years (range, 0.8-21 years). Eleven surgeons had completed a minimal number of laparoscopic cases in residency (<50), 17 surgeons had completed a moderate number of laparoscopic procedures in residency (50-200), and 21 surgeons had completed a significant number of cases during residency (>200). Of the surgeons who responded, 94% were in private practice. Fifty-seven percent of the participating surgeons who responded reported a change in laparoscopic practice patterns after the courses. Of these surgeons, 24% had a limited residency laparoscopy exposure of <50 cases. Surgeons who were exposed to ≥50 laparoscopic cases during their residency showed a statistically significant increase in the number of laparoscopic procedures performed after their class compared with surgeons who did not receive ≥50 laparoscopic cases in residency (P = .03). In addition, regardless of the procedures learned in a specific class, surgeons with ≥50 laparoscopic cases in residency had a statistically significant increase in their laparoscopic colectomy and laparoscopic hernia procedure caseload (P < .01). However, there was no statistically significant difference in laparoscopic caseload between surgeons who had completed 50 to 200 laparoscopic residency cases and those who had completed greater than 200 laparoscopic residency cases (P = .31). Furthermore, the participant's age (P = .23), practice type (P = .61), and years in practice (P = .22) had no statistical significance with regard to the adoption of laparoscopic procedures after courses taken. This finding is congruent with the findings of other researchers. Future interest in advanced laparoscopy courses was noted in 70% of surgeons and was more pronounced in surgeons with ≥50 cases in residency.
Advanced laparoscopic workshops provide an efficacious instrument in educating surgeons on minimally invasive surgical techniques. Participating surgeons significantly increased the number of course-specific procedures that they performed but also increased the number of other laparoscopic surgeries, suggesting that a certain proficiency in laparoscopic skills is translated to multiple surgical procedures. Laparoscopy experience of ≥50 cases during residency is a strong predictor of an increase in the number of advanced laparoscopic cases after attending courses.
新手术技术的引入使得腹腔镜手术培训成为执业外科医生的一项必要技能,但掌握新的手术技能是一项艰巨的任务。本研究旨在评估高级腹腔镜研讨会对执业外科医生病例量模式的影响。
在获得机构审查委员会批准后,我们对参加高级腹腔镜课程的执业外科医生进行了一项调查;对结果进行了统计学意义分析。这些课程于2002年1月至2010年12月在内布拉斯加大学医学中心举行。问卷通过邮寄、传真和电子邮件发送给外科医生。
在参加高级腹腔镜课程的109名外科医生中,79名收到了调查问卷,30名因隶属于内布拉斯加大学医学中心而被排除在调查之外。共收到47份回复(59%),来自41名男性和6名女性外科医生。从课程结束到完成调查的中位回复时间为13.2个月(范围为6.8 - 19.1个月)。参与调查的外科医生平均年龄为39.2岁(范围为29 - 51岁)。自住院医师培训结束后的平均时间为8.4年(范围为0.8 - 21年)。11名外科医生在住院医师培训期间完成的腹腔镜病例数量最少(<50例),17名外科医生在住院医师培训期间完成了中等数量的腹腔镜手术(50 - 200例),21名外科医生在住院医师培训期间完成了大量病例(>200例)。在回复的外科医生中,94%为私人执业。57%回复的参与调查外科医生报告在课程结束后腹腔镜手术模式发生了变化。在这些外科医生中,24%在住院医师培训期间腹腔镜手术经验有限,<50例。与在住院医师培训期间未接受≥50例腹腔镜手术的外科医生相比,在住院医师培训期间接受≥50例腹腔镜手术的外科医生在课程结束后进行的腹腔镜手术数量有统计学显著增加(P = .03)。此外,无论在特定课程中学到的手术如何,在住院医师培训期间有≥50例腹腔镜手术经验的外科医生在腹腔镜结肠切除术和腹腔镜疝修补手术病例量上有统计学显著增加(P < .01)。然而,在住院医师培训期间完成50至200例腹腔镜病例的外科医生与完成超过200例腹腔镜病例的外科医生之间,腹腔镜病例量没有统计学显著差异(P = .31)。此外,参与者的年龄(P = .23)、执业类型(P = .61)和执业年限(P = .22)在参加课程后采用腹腔镜手术方面没有统计学意义。这一发现与其他研究人员的发现一致。在70%的外科医生中发现了对高级腹腔镜课程的未来兴趣,并且在住院医师培训期间有≥50例病例的外科医生中更为明显。
高级腹腔镜研讨会为教育外科医生掌握微创外科技术提供了一种有效的手段。参与的外科医生显著增加了他们所执行的特定课程手术的数量,同时也增加了其他腹腔镜手术的数量,这表明一定程度的腹腔镜技能熟练程度可以转化为多种手术操作。住院医师培训期间腹腔镜手术经验≥50例是参加课程后高级腹腔镜病例数量增加的有力预测指标。