University of North Carolina School of Medicine, North Carolina, United States.
J Pediatr Urol. 2013 Dec;9(6 Pt B):1210-3. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2013.05.012. Epub 2013 Aug 9.
To assess the learning process of combining a web-based video of a simulated surgical procedure with a step-by-step checklist of the same procedure in achieving competency of the simulated technique, in this case a newborn clamp circumcision. Fundamental to this particular learning process is immediate mentor step-by-step feedback which specifically follows the procedure's step-by-step checklist.
Pediatric residents naïve to newborn circumcision were enrolled (n = 7). A circumcision simulator, instruments, and web access to the learning module were provided. Residents trained independently and then performed two simulations with the mentor. The first simulation was completed with formative scored feedback. The learner then performed a second scored simulation.
All learners showed improvement between the first and second simulation (mean 85.3-97.4). All residents achieved competency (96/100 or greater) by the second simulation. On post-procedure surveys, learners demonstrated increased comfort and reduced apprehension in performing the procedure.
Combining a web-accessible video of a procedure, a checklist, and a simulator followed by a single mentor session with immediate formative feedback which follows the steps of the checklist is a useful method to teach the simulation technique of circumcision. We plan to study if this paradigm is transferable to clinical circumcision.
评估将模拟手术过程的网络视频与相同过程的逐步检查表相结合,以实现模拟技术(在此情况下为新生儿夹式包皮环切术)能力的学习过程。这种特殊学习过程的基础是即时导师的逐步反馈,该反馈专门遵循步骤检查表。
纳入了对新生儿包皮环切术一无所知的儿科住院医师(n=7)。提供了包皮环切模拟器、器械和学习模块的网络访问权限。住院医师独立培训,然后与导师一起进行了两次模拟操作。第一次模拟操作完成后,会获得形成性评分反馈。然后,学习者进行了第二次评分模拟操作。
所有学习者在第一次和第二次模拟操作之间都有所提高(平均为 85.3-97.4)。所有住院医师在第二次模拟操作中均达到了能力标准(96/100 或更高)。在术后调查中,学习者在进行手术时表现出更高的舒适度和降低的担忧感。
将过程的可访问网络视频、检查表和模拟器相结合,然后由导师进行一次会议,并立即提供遵循检查表步骤的形成性反馈,是一种教授包皮环切模拟技术的有用方法。我们计划研究这种模式是否可以转移到临床包皮环切术。