Radboud University Nijmegen, Behavioural Science Institute, Department of Work and Organizational Psychology, PO Box 9104, 6500 HE, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Scand J Work Environ Health. 2013 Nov;39(6):535-49. doi: 10.5271/sjweh.3376. Epub 2013 Aug 12.
The objective of this study was to review longitudinal and intervention studies examining the association between psychosocial work characteristics (eg, job demands, job control, and social support) and sleep quality. Our main research aims were to examine whether (i) psychosocial work characteristics are a predictor of sleep quality, and (ii) sleep quality, in turn, is a predictor of psychosocial work characteristics.
A systematic literature search resulted in 20 relevant papers, of which 16 were longitudinal studies and 3 were intervention studies (1 study was discussed in separate papers). To quantify results, we assessed the strength of evidence of all examined associations and subsequently evaluated the studies' research quality based on predefined quality criteria.
One intervention and three longitudinal studies studies were categorized as being of high-quality. In longitudinal studies, we found consistent and strong evidence for a negative relation between job demands and sleep quality as well as evidence for a positive relation between job control and sleep quality. Other psychosocial work characteristics were examined in an insufficient number of (high-quality) studies. Moreover, both intervention studies as well as studies investigating reversed and reciprocal relations are rare, which further limits the possibility of drawing conclusions on causality.
Based on the current literature, it can be concluded that high job demands and low job control are predictors of poor sleep quality. More high-quality research is needed to examine the possible causal relationship between these and other psychosocial work characteristics with sleep quality, in addition to research focusing on reversed and reciprocal relations.
本研究旨在回顾纵向和干预研究,以考察心理社会工作特征(如工作需求、工作控制和社会支持)与睡眠质量之间的关系。我们的主要研究目的是检验以下两点:(i)心理社会工作特征是否是睡眠质量的预测因素;(ii)睡眠质量反过来是否是心理社会工作特征的预测因素。
系统文献检索得到了 20 篇相关文献,其中 16 篇为纵向研究,3 篇为干预研究(1 项研究在不同的论文中讨论)。为了量化结果,我们评估了所有被检查关联的证据强度,然后根据预先设定的质量标准评估研究的质量。
一项干预研究和三项纵向研究被归类为高质量研究。在纵向研究中,我们发现工作需求与睡眠质量呈负相关,工作控制与睡眠质量呈正相关,这两者之间存在一致且强烈的关联。其他心理社会工作特征在足够数量的(高质量)研究中进行了检验。此外,干预研究以及研究反向和相互关系的研究都很少,这进一步限制了对因果关系得出结论的可能性。
根据目前的文献,可以得出结论,高工作需求和低工作控制是睡眠质量差的预测因素。需要更多高质量的研究来检验这些以及其他心理社会工作特征与睡眠质量之间可能的因果关系,此外还需要研究关注反向和相互关系。