Public Health Services, Ministry of Health, Israel.
Environ Int. 2013 Sep;59:478-84. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2013.07.012. Epub 2013 Aug 18.
The Ministry of Health Biomonitoring Study estimated exposure of individuals in the Israeli population to bisphenol A (BPA), organophosphate (OP) pesticides, phthalates, cotinine, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and the phytoestrogenic compounds genistein and daidzein.
In 2011, 250 individuals (ages 20-74) were recruited from five different regions in Israel. Urine samples were collected and questionnaire data were obtained, including detailed dietary data (food frequency questionnaire and 24hour recall). Urinary samples were analyzed for BPA, OP metabolites (dialkyl phosphates), phthalate metabolites, cotinine, PAH metabolites, genistein, and daidzein.
BPA urinary concentrations were above the limit of quantification (LOQ) in 89% of the samples whereas urinary concentrations of phthalate metabolites were above the LOQ in 92-100% of the samples. PAH metabolites were above the LOQ in 63-99% of the samples whereas OP metabolites were above the LOQ in 44-100% of the samples. All non-smoking participants had detectable levels of cotinine in their urine; 63% had levels above the LOQ, and the rate of quantification was high compared to the general non-smoking population in Canada. Median creatinine adjusted concentrations of several OP metabolites (dimethyl phosphate, dimethyl thiophosphate) were high in our study population compared to the general US and Canadian populations. Median creatinine adjusted urinary BPA concentrations in the study population were comparable to those in Belgium and Korea; higher than those reported for the general US, German, and Canadian populations; and very low compared to health-based threshold values. Phthalate concentrations were higher in our study population compared to the general US population but values were very low compared to health-based threshold values. Median creatinine adjusted PAH concentrations were generally comparable to those reported for the general US population; median creatinine adjusted daidzein concentrations were high in our population compared to the general US population whereas genistein concentrations were comparable.
We interpreted observed urinary contaminant levels observed in our study by comparing values with health-based threshold values and/or values from international human biomonitoring studies. Using this data interpretation scheme, we identified two contaminants as being of potential public health concern and high priority for public health policy intervention: environmental tobacco smoke (ETS) and OP pesticides. We used the data collected in this study to support public health policy interventions. We plan to conduct a follow-up biomonitoring study in 2015 to measure ETS and OP exposure in the general population in Israel, to evaluate the effectiveness of relevant policy interventions.
卫生部生物监测研究估计了以色列人群中个体接触双酚 A(BPA)、有机磷(OP)杀虫剂、邻苯二甲酸酯、可替宁、多环芳烃(PAH)以及植物雌激素染料木黄酮和大豆苷元的情况。
2011 年,从以色列五个不同地区招募了 250 名(20-74 岁)个体。采集尿液样本并获得问卷数据,包括详细的饮食数据(食物频率问卷和 24 小时回顾法)。对尿液样本进行 BPA、OP 代谢物(二烷基磷酸盐)、邻苯二甲酸酯代谢物、可替宁、PAH 代谢物、染料木黄酮和大豆苷元的分析。
89%的样本中 BPA 尿液浓度高于定量限(LOQ),而 92-100%的样本中邻苯二甲酸酯代谢物的浓度高于 LOQ。63-99%的样本中 PAH 代谢物浓度高于 LOQ,而 44-100%的样本中 OP 代谢物浓度高于 LOQ。所有不吸烟的参与者尿液中都可检测到可替宁,63%的人浓度高于 LOQ,而且与加拿大一般非吸烟人群相比,定量率很高。与一般美国和加拿大人群相比,研究人群中几种 OP 代谢物(磷酸二甲酯、磷酸二甲硫酯)的肌酐调整中位数浓度较高。研究人群中的 BPA 尿液浓度与比利时和韩国的浓度相当;高于一般美国、德国和加拿大人群的报告值;与基于健康的阈值相比,非常低。与一般美国人群相比,我们研究人群中的邻苯二甲酸酯浓度较高,但与基于健康的阈值相比,浓度非常低。一般来说,PAH 的肌酐调整中位数浓度与一般美国人群的报告值相当;与一般美国人群相比,研究人群中的肌酐调整中位数染料木黄酮浓度较高,而大豆苷元浓度相当。
我们通过将观察到的尿液污染物水平与基于健康的阈值和/或国际人体生物监测研究的值进行比较来解释我们研究中观察到的情况。使用这种数据解释方案,我们确定了两种可能对公共健康构成威胁的污染物,并将其作为公共卫生政策干预的高优先事项:环境烟草烟雾(ETS)和 OP 杀虫剂。我们使用这项研究中收集的数据来支持公共卫生政策干预。我们计划在 2015 年进行一项后续生物监测研究,以测量以色列一般人群中 ETS 和 OP 的暴露情况,评估相关政策干预的效果。