Guagliardo Joseph G, Hoiriis Kathryn T
J Chiropr Educ. 2013 Fall;27(2):116-22. doi: 10.7899/JCE-13-10. Epub 2013 Aug 21.
Objective : We report the differences in final examination scores achieved by students at the culmination of two different teaching strategies in an introductory skills course. Methods : Multiple choice examination scores from six consecutive academic calendar sessions over 18 months (n = 503) were compared. Two groups were used: Cohort A (n = 290) represented students who were enrolled in the course 3 consecutive academic sessions before an instructional change and Cohort B (n = 213) included students who were enrolled in 3 consecutive academic sessions following the instructional change, which included a more active learning format. Statistical analyses used were 2-tailed independent t-test, one-way ANOVA, Tukey's honestly significant difference (HSD), and effect size. Results : The 2-tailed independent t-test revealed a significant difference between the two groups (t = -3.71, p < .001; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.29-4.20). Significant difference was found in the highest performing subgroup compared to the lowest performing subgroup in Cohort A (F = 3.343, p = .037). For Cohort A subgroups 1 and 2, Tukey's HSD was p < .028. In Cohort B, no difference was found among subgroups (F = 1.912, p = .150, HSD p > .105). Conclusion : Compared to previous versions of the same course taught by the same instructor, the students in the new course design performed better, suggesting that using active learning techniques helps improve student achievement.
我们报告了在一门基础技能课程中,两种不同教学策略结束时学生期末考试成绩的差异。方法:比较了18个月内连续六个学术日历学期的多项选择题考试成绩(n = 503)。使用了两组:A组(n = 290)代表在教学变革前连续三个学术学期注册该课程的学生,B组(n = 213)包括在教学变革后连续三个学术学期注册的学生,教学变革包括更积极的学习形式。所使用的统计分析方法有双尾独立t检验、单因素方差分析、图基真实显著差异检验(HSD)和效应量。结果:双尾独立t检验显示两组之间存在显著差异(t = -3.71,p < .001;95%置信区间[CI] 1.29 - 4.20)。在A组中,成绩最高的亚组与成绩最低的亚组相比存在显著差异(F = 3.343,p = .037)。对于A组的亚组1和亚组2,图基HSD检验的p < .028。在B组中,亚组之间未发现差异(F = 1.912,p = .150,HSD检验p > .105)。结论:与同一教师之前教授的同一课程版本相比,新课程设计中的学生表现更好,这表明使用积极学习技术有助于提高学生成绩。