Gillispie Veronica
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Ochsner Baptist, New Orleans, LA; The University of Queensland School of Medicine, Ochsner Clinical School, New Orleans, LA.
Ochsner J. 2016 Spring;16(1):32-6.
The flipped classroom is a student-centered approach to learning that increases active learning for the student compared to traditional classroom-based instruction. In the flipped classroom model, students are first exposed to the learning material through didactics outside of the classroom, usually in the form of written material, voice-over lectures, or videos. During the formal teaching time, an instructor facilitates student-driven discussion of the material via case scenarios, allowing for complex problem solving, peer interaction, and a deep understanding of the concepts. A successful flipped classroom should have three goals: (1) allow the students to become critical thinkers, (2) fully engage students and instructors, and (3) stimulate the development of a deep understanding of the material. The flipped classroom model includes teaching and learning methods that can appeal to all four generations in the academic environment.
During the 2015 academic year, we implemented the flipped classroom in the obstetrics and gynecology clerkship for the Ochsner Clinical School in New Orleans, LA. Voice-over presentations of the lectures that had been given to students in prior years were recorded and made available to the students through an online classroom. Weekly problem-based learning sessions matched to the subjects of the traditional lectures were held, and the faculty who had previously presented the information in the traditional lecture format facilitated the problem-based learning sessions. The knowledge base of students was evaluated at the end of the rotation via a multiple-choice question examination and the Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) as had been done in previous years. We compared demographic information and examination scores for traditional teaching and flipped classroom groups of students. The traditional teaching group consisted of students from Rotation 2 and Rotation 3 of the 2014 academic year who received traditional classroom-based instruction. The flipped classroom group consisted of students from Rotation 2 and Rotation 3 of the 2015 academic year who received formal didactics via voice-over presentation and had the weekly problem-based learning sessions.
When comparing the students taught by traditional methods to those taught in the flipped classroom model, we saw a statistically significant increase in test scores on the multiple-choice question examination in both the obstetrics and gynecology sections in Rotation 2. While the average score for the flipped classroom group increased in Rotation 3 on the obstetrics section of the multiple-choice question examination, the difference was not statistically significant. Unexpectedly, the average score on the gynecology portion of the multiple-choice question examination decreased among the flipped classroom group compared to the traditional teaching group, and this decrease was statistically significant. For both the obstetrics and the gynecology portions of the OSCE, we saw statistically significant increases in the scores for the flipped classroom group in both Rotation 2 and Rotation 3 compared to the traditional teaching group. With the exception of the gynecology portion of the multiple-choice question examination in Rotation 3, we saw improvement in scores after the implementation of the flipped classroom.
The flipped classroom is a feasible and useful alternative to the traditional classroom. It is a method that embraces Generation Y's need for active learning in a group setting while maintaining a traditional classroom method for introducing the information. Active learning increases student engagement and can lead to improved retention of material as demonstrated on standard examinations.
翻转课堂是一种以学生为中心的学习方法,与传统的基于课堂讲授的教学方式相比,它能增加学生的主动学习。在翻转课堂模式中,学生首先通过课堂外的教学方法接触学习材料,通常是书面材料、旁白讲座或视频的形式。在正式教学时间里,教师通过案例场景促进学生对材料进行自主讨论,从而实现复杂问题的解决、同伴互动以及对概念的深入理解。一个成功的翻转课堂应该有三个目标:(1)让学生成为批判性思考者;(2)使学生和教师充分参与;(3)激发对材料的深入理解。翻转课堂模式包含的教学方法能够吸引学术环境中的四代人。
在2015学年,我们在路易斯安那州新奥尔良市奥克施纳临床医学院的妇产科实习中实施了翻转课堂。录制了前几年给学生讲授的讲座的旁白演示,并通过在线课堂提供给学生。每周举行与传统讲座主题相匹配的基于问题的学习课程,之前以传统讲座形式呈现信息的教师负责组织基于问题的学习课程。在轮转结束时,通过多项选择题考试和客观结构化临床考试(OSCE)对学生的知识库进行评估,评估方式与前几年相同。我们比较了传统教学组和翻转课堂组学生的人口统计学信息和考试成绩。传统教学组由2014学年第2轮和第3轮接受传统课堂教学的学生组成。翻转课堂组由2015学年第2轮和第3轮通过旁白演示接受正式教学并参加每周基于问题的学习课程的学生组成。
将传统教学方法授课的学生与翻转课堂模式授课的学生进行比较时,我们发现第2轮妇产科部分的多项选择题考试成绩有统计学意义的显著提高。虽然第3轮多项选择题考试的妇产科部分,翻转课堂组的平均成绩有所提高,但差异无统计学意义。出乎意料的是,与传统教学组相比,翻转课堂组多项选择题考试的妇科部分平均成绩下降,且这种下降具有统计学意义。对于OSCE的妇产科和妇科部分,与传统教学组相比,我们发现第2轮和第3轮翻转课堂组的成绩均有统计学意义的显著提高。除了第3轮多项选择题考试的妇科部分外,实施翻转课堂后我们看到了成绩的提高。
翻转课堂是传统课堂可行且有用的替代方式。它是一种满足Y世代在小组环境中主动学习需求的方法,同时保留了传统的课堂信息引入方式。主动学习提高了学生的参与度,并如标准考试所示,能提高对材料的记忆。