Thind Amardeep, Stewart Moira, Manuel Douglas, Freeman Tom, Terry Amanda, Chevendra Vijaya, Maddocks Heather, Marshall Neil
Department of Epidemiology & Biostatistics, Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry, University of Western Ontario, London, ON.
Healthc Policy. 2012 Aug;8(1):80-91.
Reducing wait times is a key goal of Canadian health planners and policy makers. Using data from the EMRs of 23 family physicians across southwestern Ontario, we present data on wait times to see a specialist, and evaluate these data for equity.
Cross-sectional analysis of EMR database of 29,303 patients and 544,398 encounters from October 2005 to July 2010. Wait time was calculated as the difference between the specialist appointment date and the family physician's referral date. Multilevel regression analysis was used to assess equity in waiting times.
The median wait was 53 days, with female patients having a slightly longer wait than males (55 vs. 51 days), and younger patients (median = 45 days) having the shortest wait. Differences were noted among practices, with a range of 42-63 days. The longest waits were for neurosurgery (median = 103 days) and the shortest for paediatricians (median = 28 days). There was no correlation between wait times and income, but significant associations were noted for patient age, sex and referral urgency.
This is the first study to present data on actual wait times for a broad array of specialists over a five-year period. There is variation among specialties and by practice, and further research is needed to understand reasons for these. From a policy perspective, there is equity in wait times in southwestern Ontario, as waits are not correlated with SES. Future work should model the patient-, physician- and contextual-level factors that determine specialist wait times.
缩短等待时间是加拿大医疗规划者和政策制定者的关键目标。我们利用安大略省西南部23位家庭医生电子病历中的数据,呈现了看专科医生的等待时间数据,并对这些数据的公平性进行了评估。
对2005年10月至2010年7月期间29303名患者和544398次诊疗的电子病历数据库进行横断面分析。等待时间计算为专科医生预约日期与家庭医生转诊日期之间的差值。采用多水平回归分析评估等待时间的公平性。
中位等待时间为53天,女性患者的等待时间略长于男性(55天对51天),年轻患者(中位值 = 45天)的等待时间最短。不同诊所之间存在差异,范围在42 - 63天之间。等待时间最长的是神经外科(中位值 = 103天),最短的是儿科医生(中位值 = 28天)。等待时间与收入之间没有相关性,但在患者年龄、性别和转诊紧急程度方面存在显著关联。
这是第一项呈现五年期间众多专科医生实际等待时间数据的研究。各专科之间以及不同诊所之间存在差异,需要进一步研究以了解其原因。从政策角度来看,安大略省西南部在等待时间方面具有公平性,因为等待时间与社会经济地位无关。未来的工作应该对决定专科医生等待时间的患者、医生和环境层面因素进行建模。