Faust Halley S
*MPH, 1260 Vallecita Drive, Santa Fe, NM 87501, USA.
J Med Philos. 2013 Oct;38(5):539-58. doi: 10.1093/jmp/jht039. Epub 2013 Aug 24.
Clinical primary prevention eliminates or preempts either a susceptibility or risk (synergistically a cause) in order to avoid a specific harm. Philosophically, primary prevention gets caught in the metaphysical controversy of the "hard questions" of whether it is possible to "cause not" both through a positive action (preventive act causes no harm) or no action (avoiding something causes no harm). I examine my previously proposed four-step definition of the process of prevention, discuss its limitations in light of the "hard questions," and then offer a revised five-step process definition that eliminates the "cause not" concerns by changing the goal of prevention from avoiding harm, a negative state, to achieving optimal health, a positive state.
临床一级预防旨在消除或预先阻止易感性或风险(协同构成病因),以避免特定危害。从哲学角度看,一级预防陷入了形而上学的争论,即关于是否有可能通过积极行动(预防行为不造成伤害)或不采取行动(避免某些事情不造成伤害)来“不造成”某种情况这一“难题”。我审视了我之前提出的预防过程的四步定义,根据“难题”讨论了其局限性,然后提出了一个修订后的五步过程定义,通过将预防目标从避免伤害(一种消极状态)转变为实现最佳健康(一种积极状态),消除了对“不造成”的担忧。