Institute of Infection and Global Health and School of Veterinary Science, University of Liverpool, Leahurst Campus, Cheshire, UK.
BMC Vet Res. 2013 Sep 11;9:179. doi: 10.1186/1746-6148-9-179.
Gastrointestinal nematode infections constitute a threat to the health and welfare of donkeys worldwide. Their primary means of control is via anthelmintic treatments; however, use of these drugs has constraints in developing countries, including cost, limited availability, access to cheaper generic forms of variable quality and potential anthelmintic resistance. As an alternative, bioactive plants have been proposed as an option to treat and control gastrointestinal helminths in donkeys. This study aimed to use participatory methodology to explore donkey owner knowledge, attitudes and beliefs relating to the use of plant-based treatments for gastrointestinal parasites of donkeys in Ethiopia.
In focus groups, 22/29 groups stated they knew of plants used for the treatment of gastrointestinal parasites in donkeys. All groups volunteered plants that were used in cattle and/or small ruminants. In total, 21 plants were named by participants. 'Koso' (Hagenia abyssinica) 'Grawa' (Vernonia amygdalina) and a mixed roots and leaves preparation were the most frequently named plant preparations. 'Enkoko' (Embelia shimperi) and 'a mixture of roots and leaves' were ranked highly for effectiveness in donkeys. However, 'Grawa' and 'Koso' were the highest ranked when taking into account both the rank position and the number of groups ranking the plant.Thematic analysis of participants' current attitudes and beliefs surrounding traditional plant-based remedies for gastrointestinal parasites revealed that anthelmintics obtained from clinics were generally favoured due to their ease of administration and perceived higher effectiveness. There was doubt surrounding the effectiveness of some plant-based treatments, but there were also perceived advantages including their low cost, ease of cultivation and availability. However, plant-based treatments were considered a "past trend" and people favoured "modern" medicine, particularly among the younger generation.
There was extensive knowledge of plant-based treatments for gastrointestinal parasites in livestock in Ethiopia. In donkeys, Koso (Hagenia abyssinica), Grawa (Vernonia amygdalina), Enkoko (Embelia shimperi) and 'mixed roots and leaves' were the most frequently named and/or highest ranked plants with reported efficacy against gastrointestinal parasites. Further in vitro and in vivo investigation of these plants is now required to determine viable alternatives for the treatment and control of gastrointestinal parasites in Ethiopia.
胃肠道线虫感染对全球驴的健康和福利构成威胁。它们的主要控制手段是驱虫治疗;然而,在发展中国家,这些药物的使用受到限制,包括成本、可用性有限、获得更便宜的、质量参差不齐的通用形式和潜在的驱虫耐药性。作为替代方案,具有生物活性的植物已被提议作为治疗和控制驴胃肠道蠕虫的一种选择。本研究旨在使用参与式方法探讨埃塞俄比亚驴主人对使用植物治疗驴胃肠道寄生虫的知识、态度和信念。
在焦点小组中,29 个小组中有 22 个小组表示他们知道用于治疗驴胃肠道寄生虫的植物。所有小组都自愿提供了用于牛和/或小反刍动物的植物。共有 21 种植物被参与者命名。“Koso”(Hagenia abyssinica)、“Grawa”(Vernonia amygdalina)和一种混合的根和叶制剂是最常被命名的植物制剂。“Enkoko”(Embelia shimperi)和“混合的根和叶”在驴中被评为效果非常好。然而,当考虑到排名位置和将植物排名的小组数量时,“Grawa”和“Koso”的排名最高。对参与者围绕治疗胃肠道寄生虫的传统植物疗法的当前态度和信念的主题分析表明,由于诊所获得的驱虫剂易于管理和被认为更有效,因此一般更受欢迎。一些植物疗法的有效性受到怀疑,但也有一些被认为具有优势,包括成本低、易于种植和可用性。然而,植物疗法被认为是“过去的趋势”,人们更喜欢“现代”医学,尤其是在年轻一代中。
埃塞俄比亚的家畜中广泛了解用于治疗胃肠道寄生虫的植物疗法。在驴中,Koso(Hagenia abyssinica)、Grawa(Vernonia amygdalina)、Enkoko(Embelia shimperi)和“混合的根和叶”是最常被提及和/或被评为具有治疗胃肠道寄生虫功效的最高排名的植物。现在需要进一步对这些植物进行体外和体内研究,以确定在埃塞俄比亚治疗和控制胃肠道寄生虫的可行替代品。