Boyle C A, Decouflé P
Center for Environmental Health and Injury Control, Centers for Disease Control, Atlanta, GA 30333.
Am J Epidemiol. 1990 Jan;131(1):160-8. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a115470.
The completeness of death reporting and characteristics of deaths not found by the Social Security Administration, Internal Revenue Service, Veterans Administration, and National Death Index were investigated in a follow-up study (1965-1983) of mortality among 18,313 randomly selected Vietnam-era veterans. Overall, 97% of all known deaths identified by these means had been found by the National Death Index (for the years 1979-1983), 83% by the Social Security Administration files, 80% by the Veterans Administration file, and only 23% by the Internal Revenue Service file. Coverage by the Veterans Administration file differed considerably by time period of death; 28% of deaths occurring in 1965-1971 appeared in the Veterans Administration system compared with 87% in 1972-1983. Social Security Administration coverage varied somewhat over time-87% in the period from 1965-1981 and 64% in 1982-1983. Deaths not found by the National Death Index or the Veterans Administration file occurred more frequently among those with certain characteristics, such as nonwhite racial background, nonhonorable discharge, and low rank at discharge. There were no such differences for deaths found by the Social Security Administration. Importantly, these characteristics were strong predictors of subsequent mortality. Thus, in studies of mortality, there is a potential for bias when certain reporting sources are used to the exclusion of others.
在一项针对18313名随机挑选的越战时期退伍军人死亡率的随访研究(1965 - 1983年)中,对社会保障管理局、美国国税局、退伍军人管理局和国家死亡索引未发现的死亡报告完整性及死亡特征进行了调查。总体而言,通过这些途径确定的所有已知死亡中,97%已被国家死亡索引发现(1979 - 1983年期间),83%被社会保障管理局档案发现,80%被退伍军人管理局档案发现,而国税局档案仅发现23%。退伍军人管理局档案的覆盖范围因死亡时间段而异;1965 - 1971年发生的死亡中有28%出现在退伍军人管理局系统,而1972 - 1983年这一比例为87%。社会保障管理局的覆盖范围随时间略有变化——1965 - 1981年期间为87%,1982 - 1983年为64%。国家死亡索引或退伍军人管理局档案未发现的死亡在具有某些特征的人群中更为常见,如非白人种族背景、非荣誉退伍以及退伍时军衔较低。社会保障管理局发现的死亡情况不存在此类差异。重要的是,这些特征是后续死亡率的有力预测指标。因此,在死亡率研究中,若仅使用某些报告来源而排除其他来源,可能会存在偏差。