Vogel S A
Department of Special Education, Eastern Michigan University, Ypsilanti 48197.
J Learn Disabil. 1990 Jan;23(1):44-52. doi: 10.1177/002221949002300111.
A substantial body of research confirms higher verbal ability in normally achieving females and higher visual-spatial and mathematical abilities in normally achieving males. However, the specific nature of these differences varies by age, specific measure, magnitude, and variability within the groups. Re-analysis of earlier research showed that, although differences in visual-spatial ability were larger than verbal ability differences, gender differences did not account for more than 1% to 5% of the group variance. In the population with learning disabilities (LD), research must be interpreted cautiously because LD samples were drawn mainly from the system-identified population and may reflect selection bias. Findings indicate that system-identified females with LD are lower in IQ, have more severe academic achievement deficits in some aspects of reading and math, and are somewhat better in visual-motor abilities, spelling, and written language mechanics than males with LD. In mathematics, however, it is difficult to document consistent differences in computational skills in the elementary school ages. More consistent findings, however, indicate superiority in mathematical reasoning in males with LD. A limited number of studies on research-identified samples indicate that findings from studies of school-identified LD samples must be interpreted cautiously because females with LD identified in the schools may not be representative of females with LD in general.
大量研究证实,正常发育的女性语言能力较强,正常发育的男性视觉空间和数学能力较强。然而,这些差异的具体性质因年龄、具体测量方法、差异程度以及群体内部的变异性而异。对早期研究的重新分析表明,尽管视觉空间能力的差异大于语言能力的差异,但性别差异在群体方差中所占比例不超过1%至5%。在学习障碍(LD)人群中,研究结果必须谨慎解读,因为LD样本主要来自系统识别的人群,可能存在选择偏差。研究结果表明,系统识别出的患有LD的女性智商较低,在阅读和数学的某些方面学业成绩缺陷更严重,在视觉运动能力、拼写和书面语言技巧方面比患有LD的男性略胜一筹。然而,在小学阶段,很难证明在计算技能方面存在一致的性别差异。然而,更一致的研究结果表明,患有LD的男性在数学推理方面具有优势。对研究识别样本的有限研究表明,对学校识别出的LD样本的研究结果必须谨慎解读,因为学校中识别出的患有LD的女性可能并不代表一般患有LD的女性。