Benson Brian C, Mulder Christopher J, Laczek Jeffrey T
Department of Medicine, Tripler Army Medical Center, Honolulu, HI (B.C.B.).
Hawaii J Med Public Health. 2013 Sep;72(9 Suppl 4):14-7.
For patients with suspected celiac disease, the American Gastroenterological Association recommends initial screening with anti-tissue transglutaminase antibody (tTG) and confirmation testing with small bowel biopsy. However, at Tripler Army Medical Center we routinely screen patients with both tTG and anti-gliadin antibodies (AGA) in combination. The purpose of this study was to evaluate whether this dual screening method adds to the evaluation of patients with suspected celiac disease or results in more false-positive results than tTG screening alone. A retrospective chart review of all tTG and AGA screening serologies at Tripler Army Medical Center between September 2008 and March 2012 was performed. For patients with positive serologic testing, small bowel biopsy results or reasoning for deferring biopsy were investigated. tTG was found to have a higher positive predictive value for celiac disease than AGA, however AGA identified 5 patients (19% of biopsy confirmed celiac disease) that had a negative tTG and would not have been identified by tTG screening alone. Using AGA in combination with tTG should be considered if the goal of screening is to identify all patients with celiac disease, with the understanding that this strategy will generate more false positive tests and result in additional patients undergoing small bowel biopsy.
对于疑似乳糜泻的患者,美国胃肠病学会建议首先进行抗组织转谷氨酰胺酶抗体(tTG)筛查,并通过小肠活检进行确诊检测。然而,在特里普勒陆军医疗中心,我们常规同时使用tTG和抗麦醇溶蛋白抗体(AGA)对患者进行筛查。本研究的目的是评估这种双重筛查方法是否能为疑似乳糜泻患者的评估提供更多信息,或者是否会比单独使用tTG筛查产生更多假阳性结果。对2008年9月至2012年3月期间特里普勒陆军医疗中心所有tTG和AGA筛查血清学检查进行了回顾性图表审查。对于血清学检测呈阳性的患者,调查了小肠活检结果或推迟活检的原因。发现tTG对乳糜泻的阳性预测价值高于AGA,然而AGA识别出5例患者(经活检确诊的乳糜泻患者中的19%)tTG检测为阴性,单独使用tTG筛查无法识别这些患者。如果筛查的目标是识别所有乳糜泻患者,应考虑将AGA与tTG联合使用,但要明白这种策略会产生更多假阳性检测结果,并导致更多患者接受小肠活检。