Morgan-Trimmer Sarah
Cardiff University, Cardiff, CF, UK
Eval Health Prof. 2015 Sep;38(3):295-314. doi: 10.1177/0163278713497363. Epub 2013 Sep 23.
This article reflects on the current state of process evaluations of health behavior interventions and argues that evaluation practice in this area could be improved by drawing on the social science literature to a greater degree. While process evaluations of health behavior interventions have increasingly engaged with the social world and sociological aspects of interventions, there has been a lag in applying relevant and potentially useful approaches from the social sciences. This has limited the scope for health behavior process evaluations to address pertinent contextual issues and methodological challenges. Three aspects of process evaluations are discussed: the incorporation of contexts of interventions; engagement with the concept of "process" in process evaluation; and working with theory to understand interventions. Following on from this, the article also comments on the need for new methodologies and on the implications for addressing health inequalities.
本文反思了健康行为干预过程评估的现状,并认为通过更大程度地借鉴社会科学文献,该领域的评估实践可以得到改进。虽然健康行为干预的过程评估越来越多地涉及社会世界和干预的社会学方面,但在应用社会科学中相关且可能有用的方法方面存在滞后。这限制了健康行为过程评估解决相关背景问题和方法挑战的范围。本文讨论了过程评估的三个方面:干预背景的纳入;过程评估中对“过程”概念的参与;以及运用理论理解干预。在此基础上,本文还评论了新方法的必要性以及对解决健康不平等问题的影响。