Burston Sarah, Chaboyer Wendy, Gillespie Brigid
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Griffith University, Gold Coast, QLD, Australia.
J Clin Nurs. 2014 Jul;23(13-14):1785-95. doi: 10.1111/jocn.12337. Epub 2013 Sep 14.
To review nurse-sensitive indicators that may be suitable to assess nursing care quality.
Patient safety concerns, fiscal pressures and patient expectation create a demand that healthcare providers demonstrate the quality of nursing care delivered. As a result, nurse managers are increasingly encouraged to provide evidence of nursing care quality. Nurse-sensitive indicators are being proposed as a means of meeting this need.
Literature review.
A review of the literature was conducted using CINAHL and MEDLINE from 2002-2011. Key search terms were nurs* and sensitive indicators, outcome measures, indicators, metrics and patient outcomes.
Most of the research has examined the relationship between nursing structural variables and patient outcomes in acute care settings and have explored potential indicators for specific patient groups and nursing roles. When using nurse-sensitive indicators, issues concerning the selection, reporting and sustained use are important for nurse managers to consider.
Evidence for the nurse-sensitivity of some commonly used indicators is inconsistent due to the disparity in definitions used, data collection and analysis methods. Further research on the application and implementation of these indicators is required to assist nurse managers in attempting to quantify the quality of nursing care. Nurses need to continue to strive to achieve agreement on the definitions of indicators, gather strong consistent evidence of nurse-sensitivity, resolve issues of regular data collection and consider selection, reporting and sustainment when implementing nurse-sensitive indicators.
Once identified, nurse-sensitive indicators can be applied for quality improvement purposes, but consensus is required to fully realise their potential. Nurse managers need to be aware of the factors that can influence the use of indicators at unit level. Strategies need to be implemented to promote these indicators becoming integrated with routine nursing care.
回顾可能适用于评估护理质量的护理敏感指标。
患者安全问题、财政压力以及患者期望使得医疗服务提供者需要证明所提供护理的质量。因此,越来越鼓励护士长提供护理质量的证据。护理敏感指标被提议作为满足这一需求的一种方式。
文献综述。
使用CINAHL和MEDLINE对2002年至2011年的文献进行综述。关键检索词为“nurs*”以及敏感指标、结局指标、指标、度量标准和患者结局。
大多数研究考察了急性护理环境中护理结构变量与患者结局之间的关系,并探索了针对特定患者群体和护理角色的潜在指标。在使用护理敏感指标时,选择、报告和持续使用等问题对于护士长来说是需要考虑的重要方面。
由于所使用定义、数据收集和分析方法的差异,一些常用指标的护理敏感性证据并不一致。需要对这些指标的应用和实施进行进一步研究,以帮助护士长试图量化护理质量。护士们需要继续努力就指标定义达成一致,收集强有力的、一致的护理敏感性证据,解决常规数据收集问题,并在实施护理敏感指标时考虑选择、报告和持续性问题。
一旦确定,护理敏感指标可用于质量改进目的,但需要达成共识才能充分发挥其潜力。护士长需要了解可能影响单位层面指标使用的因素。需要实施策略来促进这些指标与常规护理相结合。