Department of Surgical Sciences, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Bergen , Bergen, Norway.
J Sports Sci Med. 2009 Mar 1;8(1):130-5. eCollection 2009.
The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of self- reported versus diagnosed stress fractures in female elite athletes and non-athletic controls. A random sample of Norwegian elite athletes from the national teams, aged 13-39 years (n = 186) and a random sample of non-athletic controls (n = 145) in the same age group participated in the study. The athletes represented a junior- or senior team, or a recruiting squad for one of these teams, in one of 46 different sports/events. A higher percentage of athletes self-reported stress fractures (14.0%) compared to those diagnosed with stress fractures (8.1%) (p < 0.001). Six controls self- reported stress fractures, but none of them were diagnosed with stress fractures. These results indicate that self-reporting of stress fractures has low validity. This finding has important implications for further research on stress fractures in athletes. Key pointsThis study is the first to compare self-reported and diagnosed stress fractures in the total population of elite athletes representing all kinds of sports.The results indicate that self-reporting of stress fractures has low validity in both athletes and non-athletic controls, and other measurement methods should be considered when evaluating possible stress fractures.Based on our results, stress fractures seem to be a sport-related injury.
本研究旨在确定女性精英运动员和非运动员对照组中自我报告和诊断的应力性骨折的患病率。从国家队中随机抽取了年龄在 13 至 39 岁之间的 186 名挪威精英运动员和同年龄段的 145 名非运动员对照组参加了这项研究。这些运动员代表了 46 种不同运动/赛事中的一支青年队或成年队,或者是其中一支队伍的招募队伍。与诊断为应力性骨折的运动员(8.1%)相比,自我报告有应力性骨折的运动员比例更高(14.0%)(p < 0.001)。有 6 名对照组自我报告有应力性骨折,但没有一人被诊断为应力性骨折。这些结果表明,自我报告的应力性骨折的有效性较低。这一发现对运动员应力性骨折的进一步研究具有重要意义。关键点 本研究首次比较了代表各种运动的所有精英运动员人群中的自我报告和诊断的应力性骨折。 结果表明,运动员和非运动员对照组的自我报告的应力性骨折的有效性均较低,在评估可能的应力性骨折时应考虑其他测量方法。 根据我们的结果,应力性骨折似乎是一种与运动相关的损伤。