Hanson Claudia, Ronsmans Carine, Penfold Suzanne, Maokola Werner, Manzi Fatuma, Jaribu Jenny, Mbaruku Godfrey, Mshinda Hassan, Tanner Marcel, Schellenberg Joanna
Department of Disease Control, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
BMC Res Notes. 2013 Oct 30;6:435. doi: 10.1186/1756-0500-6-435.
Progress towards reaching Millennium Development Goals four (child health) and five (maternal health) is lagging behind, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, despite increasing efforts to scale up high impact interventions. Increasing the proportion of birth attended by a skilled attendant is a main indicator of progress, but not much is known about the quality of childbirth care delivered by these skilled attendants. With a view to reducing maternal mortality through health systems improvement we describe the care routinely offered in childbirth at dispensaries, health centres and hospitals in five districts in rural Southern Tanzania. We use data from a health facility census assessing 159 facilities in five districts in early 2009. A structural and operational assessment was undertaken based on staff reports using a modular questionnaire assessing staffing, work load, equipment and supplies as well as interventions routinely implemented during childbirth.
Health centres and dispensaries attended a median of eight and four deliveries every month respectively. Dispensaries had a median of 2.5 (IQR 2-3) health workers including auxiliary staff instead of the recommended four clinical officer and certified nurses. Only 28% of first-line facilities (dispensaries and health centres) reported offering active management in the third stage of labour (AMTSL). Essential childbirth care comprising eight interventions including AMTSL, infection prevention, partograph use including foetal monitoring and newborn care including early breastfeeding, thermal care at birth and prevention of ophthalmia neonatorum was offered by 5% of dispensaries, 38% of health centres and 50% of hospitals consistently. No first-line facility had provided all signal functions for emergency obstetric complications in the previous six months.
Essential interventions for childbirth care are not routinely implemented in first-line facilities or hospitals. Dispensaries have both low staffing and low caseload which constrains the ability to provide high-quality childbirth care. Improvements in quality of care are essential so that women delivering in facility receive "skilled attendance" and adequate care for common obstetric complications such as post-partum haemorrhage.
尽管加大了力度扩大高影响力干预措施的规模,但在实现千年发展目标四(儿童健康)和目标五(孕产妇健康)方面仍进展滞后,尤其是在撒哈拉以南非洲地区。增加熟练医护人员接生的比例是进展的一项主要指标,但对于这些熟练医护人员提供的分娩护理质量却知之甚少。为了通过改善卫生系统降低孕产妇死亡率,我们描述了坦桑尼亚南部农村五个地区的诊疗所、卫生中心和医院在分娩时常规提供的护理情况。我们使用了2009年初对五个地区159家机构进行评估的卫生机构普查数据。基于工作人员报告,使用一份模块化问卷进行了结构和运营评估,该问卷评估人员配备、工作量、设备和物资以及分娩期间常规实施的干预措施。
卫生中心和诊疗所每月接生的中位数分别为8例和4例。诊疗所的卫生工作者(包括辅助人员)中位数为2.5名(四分位间距为2 - 3),而推荐的临床医生和注册护士数量为4名。只有28%的一线机构(诊疗所和卫生中心)报告在第三产程提供了积极管理(AMTSL)。包括AMTSL、感染预防、使用产程图(包括胎儿监测)以及新生儿护理(包括早期母乳喂养、出生时的体温护理和预防新生儿眼炎)在内的八项基本分娩护理干预措施,分别有5%的诊疗所、38%的卫生中心和50%的医院始终提供。在前六个月中,没有一家一线机构提供了所有针对产科急诊并发症的关键功能。
分娩护理的基本干预措施在一线机构或医院并未常规实施。诊疗所人员配备不足且工作量低,这限制了提供高质量分娩护理的能力。护理质量的改善至关重要,以便在机构分娩的妇女能够获得“熟练护理”以及对常见产科并发症(如产后出血)的充分护理。