Department of Psychology, Yale University.
Department of Psychology, Princeton University.
Dev Psychol. 2014 Apr;50(4):1081-90. doi: 10.1037/a0035054. Epub 2013 Nov 11.
Whereas members of high-status racial groups show ingroup preference when attitudes are measured implicitly, members of low-status racial groups--both adults and children--typically show no bias, potentially reflecting awareness of the ingroup's low status. We hypothesized that when status differences are especially pronounced, children from low-status groups would show an implicit outgroup bias, the strength of which might relate to attitudes toward status. We tested these predictions among 6- to 11-year-old Black and Coloured (i.e., multiracial) children from South Africa, a country marked by extreme status differentials among racial groups. As a measure of implicit intergroup bias, children (N = 78) completed an Implicit Association Test (IAT), a speeded categorization task that assesses the relative strength of association between 2 target groups (in the present study, either Whites vs. Blacks or Whites vs. Coloureds) and positive vs. negative evaluation. Children also completed explicit (i.e., self-report) measures of attitudes toward racial groups as well as toward rich and poor people (a measure of attitudes toward status). Both groups of children showed an implicit outgroup-favoring (i.e., pro-White) bias, suggesting that children were sensitive to the extent of status differences. The only instance in which implicit pro-White bias did not emerge involved Black children's evaluations of Whites vs. Coloureds, both higher-status outgroups. Explicit preference for high status predicted implicit pro-White bias, particularly when the IAT contrasted 2 outgroups. The impact of status on the development of implicit and explicit intergroup bias is discussed.
高地位群体的成员在态度被内隐测量时表现出内群体偏好,而低地位群体的成员——无论是成年人还是儿童——通常没有偏见,这可能反映了他们对内群体低地位的认识。我们假设,当地位差异特别明显时,来自低地位群体的儿童会表现出内隐的外群体偏见,这种偏见的强度可能与对地位的态度有关。我们在南非的黑人和混血儿(即多种族)6 至 11 岁儿童中测试了这些预测,南非是一个种族群体之间存在极端地位差异的国家。作为内群体偏见的内隐测量,儿童(N=78)完成了内隐联想测验(IAT),这是一种快速分类任务,评估了两个目标群体(在本研究中,要么是白人对黑人,要么是白人对混血儿)与积极与消极评价之间的相对关联强度。儿童还完成了对种族群体以及对富人和穷人的态度的外显(即自我报告)测量(一种对地位的态度的测量)。两个群体的儿童都表现出内隐的外群体偏好(即支持白人),这表明儿童对地位差异的程度很敏感。内隐的支持白人偏见没有出现的唯一情况涉及黑人儿童对白人对混血儿的评价,这两个都是较高地位的外群体。对外群体的明确偏好预测了内隐的支持白人偏见,特别是当 IAT 对比两个外群体时。讨论了地位对发展内隐和外显群体偏见的影响。