Chong W, Zhang Y, Qian Y, Lai L, Parker G, Mitchell K
Monash Medical Centre, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2014 Jan;35(1):136-42. doi: 10.3174/ajnr.A3790. Epub 2013 Nov 28.
Recent studies have shown promising results regarding intracranial aneurysms treated with flow diverters. However, these have had adverse effects, including delayed aneurysm occlusion, posttreatment symptoms, and rupture. The hemodynamic profiles of aneurysms treated with flow diverters were analyzed to determine the ones associated with successful and failed treatments.
Patient-specific computational fluid dynamics were used to simulate hemodynamic profiles, including the presence of jet flow, energy loss, volume flow, and wall shear stress in 4 successful occlusions of aneurysms and 4 failed cases after flow-diverter deployment. In these 4 failed cases, hemodynamic profiles were examined again after a hypothetic second intervention. This involved replacing the failed flow diverter with a hypothetic optimally deployed flow diverter or simulated placement of a second flow diverter within the first (double hypothetic optimally deployed).
Where successful occlusions were achieved, a marked obliteration of jet flow was observed. Flow entering the aneurysm sac was diverted via the center of the flow diverter and joined smoothly with the continuation of flow leaving the aneurysm sac into the parent arteries. These observations were supplemented by a reduction in the other hemodynamic profiles. Aneurysm neck geometry might influence the efficacy of the flow diverter.
Hemodynamic indices, as calculated by using computational fluid dynamics techniques, have close correlation with flow-diverter treatment outcome. Computational fluid dynamics could be potentially useful as a planning tool for neurointerventionists by simulating an optimized flow-diverter deployment strategy before the procedure and evaluating posttreatment outcome.
近期研究显示,血流导向装置治疗颅内动脉瘤取得了令人鼓舞的结果。然而,这些治疗也存在不良反应,包括动脉瘤延迟闭塞、治疗后症状及破裂。分析血流导向装置治疗动脉瘤的血流动力学特征,以确定与治疗成功和失败相关的特征。
采用个体化计算流体动力学模拟血流动力学特征,包括4例动脉瘤成功闭塞和4例血流导向装置置入后治疗失败病例中的射流、能量损失、体积流量及壁面剪应力情况。在这4例治疗失败的病例中,假设进行二次干预后再次检查血流动力学特征。这包括用假设的最佳置入的血流导向装置替换失败的血流导向装置,或模拟在第一个装置内放置第二个血流导向装置(双重假设最佳置入)。
在成功实现闭塞的病例中,观察到射流明显消失。进入动脉瘤囊的血流通过血流导向装置的中心转向,并与离开动脉瘤囊进入母动脉的血流延续部分顺利汇合。其他血流动力学特征的降低也佐证了这些观察结果。动脉瘤颈部形态可能会影响血流导向装置的疗效。
采用计算流体动力学技术计算的血流动力学指标与血流导向装置治疗结果密切相关。通过在手术前模拟优化的血流导向装置置入策略并评估治疗后结果,计算流体动力学可能对神经介入医生作为一种规划工具具有潜在用途。