Zarbo R J, Crissman J D, Venkat H, Weiss M A
Am J Surg Pathol. 1986 Nov;10(11):741-53. doi: 10.1097/00000478-198611000-00001.
The histogenetic origin of the spindle-cell component of spindle-cell carcinoma of the head and neck mucosa remains controversial. The spindle cells have been considered a variant growth pattern of squamous-cell carcinoma, a non-neoplastic mesenchymal reaction, and a malignant admixture of epithelial and mesenchymal neoplasm. To evaluate the spindle-cell component, we studied 25 tumors (18 biphasic and seven monophasic) by utilizing the following: an avidin-biotin complex immunoperoxidase technique with a variety of antikeratin antibodies (AE1, AE3, CAM 5.2, 35BH11, and polyclonal Dako) and a monoclonal antivimentin antibody, and an avidin-biotin alkaline phosphatase double-labeling technique to detect coexpression of keratin and vimentin. The immunohistologic staining pattern was compared with electron-microscopic studies. Eight of 18 biphasic neoplasms contained immunoreactive keratin in the spindle-cell component that was distributed focally in a minority of cells in 3 tumors and diffusely throughout five of the neoplasms. Four of seven ulcerated monophasic spindle-cell tumors devoid of histologic squamous-cell carcinoma also were keratin positive, confirming epithelial differentiation. The majority of the spindle cells in all the tumors contained vimentin intermediate filaments. In three immunoperoxidase keratin positive biphasic tumors examined with alkaline phosphatase double labeling, occasional spindle cells were found that coexpressed keratin and vimentin and were interspersed with cells expressing either intermediate filament. Electron microscopy was performed on the spindle-cell component of 13 tumors, nine biphasic and four monophasic. Of the biphasic tumors, four were immunoperoxidase keratin positive; three of these showed epithelial differentiation by electron microscopy. Five biphasic tumors were keratin negative, and three tumors had epithelial differentiation by electron microscopy. Four monophasic spindle-cell tumors were immunoperoxidase keratin positive, and one of these had epithelial features by electron microscopy. Two monophasic tumors were keratin negative and without ultrastructural evidence of epithelial features. By using a combination of immunohistochemical and electron-microscopic observations, we identified evidence for epithelial differentiation in the spindled cells in 11 of 18 biphasic tumors and four of seven monophasic spindle-cell tumors.
头颈部黏膜梭形细胞癌的梭形细胞成分的组织发生学起源仍存在争议。梭形细胞曾被认为是鳞状细胞癌的一种变异生长模式、一种非肿瘤性间叶反应以及上皮和间叶肿瘤的恶性混合。为评估梭形细胞成分,我们利用以下方法研究了25例肿瘤(18例双相性和7例单相性):采用抗角蛋白抗体(AE1、AE3、CAM 5.2、35BH11和多克隆Dako)和单克隆抗波形蛋白抗体的抗生物素蛋白-生物素复合物免疫过氧化物酶技术,以及抗生物素蛋白-生物素碱性磷酸酶双标记技术来检测角蛋白和波形蛋白的共表达。将免疫组织化学染色模式与电子显微镜研究结果进行比较。18例双相性肿瘤中有8例在梭形细胞成分中含有免疫反应性角蛋白,其中3例肿瘤中角蛋白在少数细胞中局灶性分布,5例肿瘤中角蛋白弥漫性分布。7例无组织学鳞状细胞癌的溃疡性单相性梭形细胞肿瘤中有4例角蛋白也呈阳性,证实了上皮分化。所有肿瘤中的大多数梭形细胞含有波形蛋白中间丝。在3例经碱性磷酸酶双标记检测的免疫过氧化物酶角蛋白阳性的双相性肿瘤中,偶尔发现有梭形细胞同时表达角蛋白和波形蛋白,并与表达其中一种中间丝的细胞相互穿插。对13例肿瘤(9例双相性和4例单相性)的梭形细胞成分进行了电子显微镜检查。在双相性肿瘤中,4例免疫过氧化物酶角蛋白呈阳性;其中3例通过电子显微镜显示上皮分化。5例双相性肿瘤角蛋白呈阴性,3例肿瘤通过电子显微镜显示上皮分化。4例单相性梭形细胞肿瘤免疫过氧化物酶角蛋白呈阳性,其中1例通过电子显微镜具有上皮特征。2例单相性肿瘤角蛋白呈阴性,且无上皮特征的超微结构证据。通过结合免疫组织化学和电子显微镜观察,我们在18例双相性肿瘤中的11例以及7例单相性梭形细胞肿瘤中的4例的梭形细胞中发现了上皮分化的证据。