Wübken Magdalena, Oswald Jana, Schneider Antonius
Institut für Allgemeinmedizin, Klinikum rechts der Isar, TU München.
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2013;107(9-10):632-7. doi: 10.1016/j.zefq.2013.10.017. Epub 2013 Nov 8.
In general, the prevalence of diseases is low in primary care. Therefore, the positive predictive value of diagnostic tests is lower than in hospitals where patients are highly selected. In addition, the patients present with milder forms of disease; and many diseases might hide behind the initial symptom(s). These facts lead to diagnostic uncertainty which is somewhat inherent to general practice. This narrative review discusses different sources of and reasons for uncertainty and strategies to deal with it in the context of the current literature. Fear of uncertainty correlates with higher diagnostic activities. The attitude towards uncertainty correlates with the choice of medical speciality by vocational trainees or medical students. An intolerance of uncertainty, which still increases as medicine is making steady progress, might partly explain the growing shortage of general practitioners. The bio-psycho-social context appears to be important to diagnostic decision-making. The effect of intuition and heuristics are investigated by cognitive psychologists. It is still unclear whether these aspects are prone to bias or useful, which might depend on the context of medical decisions. Good communication is of great importance to share uncertainty with the patients in a transparent way and to alleviate shared decision-making. Dealing with uncertainty should be seen as an important core component of general practice and needs to be investigated in more detail to improve the respective medical decisions.
一般来说,基层医疗中疾病的患病率较低。因此,诊断测试的阳性预测值低于对患者进行高度筛选的医院。此外,基层医疗中的患者所患疾病症状较轻;而且许多疾病可能隐藏在初始症状背后。这些事实导致了诊断的不确定性,这在一定程度上是全科医疗所固有的。这篇叙述性综述在当前文献的背景下讨论了不确定性的不同来源和原因以及应对策略。对不确定性的恐惧与更高的诊断活动相关。对不确定性的态度与实习医生或医学生对医学专业的选择相关。随着医学不断进步,对不确定性的不耐受仍在增加,这可能部分解释了全科医生日益短缺的现象。生物 - 心理 - 社会背景似乎对诊断决策很重要。认知心理学家研究了直觉和启发式方法的作用。目前尚不清楚这些方面是否容易产生偏差或是否有用,这可能取决于医疗决策的背景。良好的沟通对于以透明的方式与患者分享不确定性以及促进共同决策至关重要。应对不确定性应被视为全科医疗的一个重要核心组成部分,需要更详细地进行研究以改善相应的医疗决策。