McNeil Ryan, Shannon Kate, Shaver Laura, Kerr Thomas, Small Will
BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
BC Centre for Excellence in HIV/AIDS, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada; Department of Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Int J Drug Policy. 2014 May;25(3):608-15. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2013.11.006. Epub 2013 Nov 22.
Vancouver's Downtown Eastside is home to Canada's largest street-based drug scene and only supervised injection facility (Insite). High levels of violence among men and women have been documented in this neighbourhood. This study was undertaken to explore the role of violence in shaping the socio-spatial relations of women and 'marginal men' (i.e., those occupying subordinate positions within the drug scene) in the Downtown Eastside, including access to Insite.
Semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted with 23 people who inject drugs (PWID) recruited through the Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users, a local drug user organization. Interviews included a mapping exercise. Interview transcripts and maps were analyzed thematically, with an emphasis on how gendered violence shaped participants' spatial practices.
Hegemonic forms of masculinity operating within the Downtown Eastside framed the everyday violence experienced by women and marginal men. This violence shaped the spatial practices of women and marginal men, in that they avoided drug scene milieus where they had experienced violence or that they perceived to be dangerous. Some men linked their spatial restrictions to the perceived 'dope quality' of neighbourhood drug dealers to maintain claims to dominant masculinities while enacting spatial strategies to promote safety. Environmental supports provided by health and social care agencies were critical in enabling women and marginal men to negotiate place and survival within the context of drug scene violence. Access to Insite did not motivate participants to enter into "dangerous" drug scene milieus but they did venture into these areas if necessary to obtain drugs or generate income.
Gendered violence is critical in restricting the geographies of men and marginal men within the street-based drug scene. There is a need to scale up existing environmental interventions, including supervised injection services, to minimize violence and potential drug-related risks among these highly-vulnerable PWID.
温哥华的市中心东区是加拿大最大的街头毒品交易场所所在地,也是唯一的受监管注射设施(英赛特)所在地。该社区记录到男女之间存在高度暴力行为。本研究旨在探讨暴力在塑造市中心东区女性和“边缘男性”(即在毒品交易场所中处于从属地位的男性)的社会空间关系方面所起的作用,包括使用英赛特设施的情况。
通过当地吸毒者组织温哥华地区吸毒者网络招募了23名注射毒品者(PWID),对其进行了半结构化定性访谈。访谈包括一次绘图练习。对访谈记录和地图进行了主题分析,重点关注性别暴力如何塑造参与者的空间行为。
市中心东区存在的霸权男性气质形式构成了女性和边缘男性所经历的日常暴力。这种暴力塑造了女性和边缘男性的空间行为,即他们避开曾经历暴力或认为危险的毒品交易场所环境。一些男性将他们的空间限制与对邻里毒贩“毒品质量”的认知联系起来,以维持对主导男性气质的主张,同时制定空间策略以促进安全。健康和社会护理机构提供的环境支持对于使女性和边缘男性在毒品交易场所暴力的背景下协商场所和生存至关重要。使用英赛特设施并没有促使参与者进入“危险”的毒品交易场所环境,但他们确实会在必要时冒险进入这些区域以获取毒品或赚取收入。
性别暴力在限制街头毒品交易场所中男性和边缘男性的地理分布方面至关重要。有必要扩大现有的环境干预措施,包括受监管注射服务,以尽量减少这些高度脆弱的注射毒品者中的暴力行为和潜在的毒品相关风险。