Ali M. Hashmi, MD, Foreign Professor III (HEC), Psychiatry, King Edward Medical University/Mayo Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan.
Muhammad Awais Aftab, MBBS, Department of Psychiatry, King Edward Medical University/Mayo Hospital, Lahore, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2013 Sep;29(5):1094-8. doi: 10.12669/pjms.295.3882.
Saadat Hasan 'Manto' is widely acknowledged as one of the greatest short story writers in the world. He died at the age of forty three from complications of alcoholism. All of his life, he suffered from symptoms of anxiety and depression and his alcohol abuse was intimately linked both to his mental distress as well as his creative genius. This paper examines the life of Manto from a psychiatric perspective and the link between creativity and mental illness. We show how Manto's particular family circumstances led to the development of restlessness and later anxiety in his life; how his substance abuse, especially alcohol abuse exacerbated this mental distress and how it eventually led to his death and how all of these factors were intimately linked to his creative genius and were the source of so many of his literary masterpieces.
We reviewed seventy five short stories considered to be his best. Writings about Manto's life including his own were reviewed to construct a picture of his life as well as find clues to his mental distress and alcohol abuse. A literature search for articles related to creativity and mental illness was conducted using Google Scholar containing the search terms 'creativity and madness' and 'creativity and mental illness' in the titles of the articles. References most relevant to our case study were identified.
Manto suffered from symptoms of anxiety and depression which today would meet the diagnostic criteria for Alcohol Dependence and, in later life, Alcohol-induced Psychosis. Appropriate treatment may have prolonged his life although that may have come at the expense of his creativity.
萨达特·哈桑·曼托 (Saadat Hasan Manto) 被广泛认为是世界上最伟大的短篇小说作家之一。他因酗酒并发症去世,享年四十三岁。他一生都患有焦虑和抑郁症状,他的酗酒与他的精神困扰以及创作天赋密切相关。本文从精神病学的角度探讨了曼托的生活以及创造力和精神疾病之间的联系。我们展示了曼托特殊的家庭环境如何导致他生活中的不安和后来的焦虑;他的物质滥用,尤其是酗酒,如何加剧了这种精神困扰,最终导致他的死亡;以及所有这些因素如何与他的创作天赋密切相关,成为他许多文学杰作的源泉。
我们回顾了被认为是他最好的七十五篇短篇小说。回顾了关于曼托生活的作品,包括他自己的作品,以描绘他的生活,并寻找他精神困扰和酗酒的线索。使用 Google Scholar 进行了与创造力和精神疾病相关的文章的文献检索,在文章标题中包含了“创造力和疯狂”和“创造力和精神疾病”的搜索词。确定了与我们的案例研究最相关的参考文献。
曼托患有焦虑和抑郁症状,如果放在今天,这些症状将符合酒精依赖的诊断标准,而在后期,还会出现酒精引起的精神病。适当的治疗可能会延长他的生命,尽管这可能会以牺牲他的创造力为代价。