Obstetrics and Maternal-Fetal Medicine, GHU Necker-Enfants Malades, AP-HP, Université Paris Descartes, France.
Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2014 Mar;43(3):311-6. doi: 10.1002/uog.13288. Epub 2014 Feb 12.
To compare the performance of traditional growth charts for estimated fetal weight (EFW) and a validated pragmatic probabilistic approach using biometry at 31-34 weeks' gestation to screen for late pregnancy small-for-gestational age (SGA) fetuses in a low-risk population.
Records of ultrasound biometry at 31-34 weeks were reviewed in 7755 consecutive low-risk women between 2002 and 2011. Fetal malformations, Doppler anomalies and preterm delivery before 37 weeks were excluded. SGA was defined by various percentile cut-offs of birth weight. The probability of SGA was modeled as a function of Z-scores of femur length, abdominal circumference and head circumference. The model was validated on a second independent dataset of 1725 pregnancies from a different screening unit. The screening performance of this probabilistic approach was compared with those of traditional EFW growth charts. The additional value of factoring in maternal characteristics was also ascertained.
Using national birth-weight charts, the proportions of newborns at 37-42 weeks with birth weight<3(rd) , <5(th) and<10(th) centiles were 3%, 6% and 12%, respectively, and there was a 2% rate of birth weight<2500 g. For a 10% false-positive rate, a direct probabilistic approach yielded a 51% detection rate of neonates with birth weight<10(th) centile, compared to the 32% and 48% detection rates given by the 10(th) centile cut-off of two reference charts for EFW. Adding maternal characteristics significantly improved detection rate by 2% to 53%.
The suggested validated approach to screening for late SGA fetuses outperforms traditional approaches using growth charts. By adding maternal characteristics, this screening method offers a favorable alternative to customized charts.
比较传统的胎儿估重生长曲线(EFW)和一种经过验证的实用概率方法在 31-34 孕周时的表现,以筛查低危人群中晚期妊娠小于胎龄儿(SGA)胎儿。
回顾 2002 年至 2011 年间 7755 例连续的低危孕妇的 31-34 周超声生物测量记录。排除胎儿畸形、多普勒异常和 37 周前早产。SGA 定义为出生体重的各种百分位截断值。将 SGA 的概率建模为股骨长、腹围和头围 Z 分数的函数。该模型在来自另一个筛查单位的 1725 例妊娠的独立数据集上进行了验证。比较了这种概率方法与传统 EFW 生长曲线的筛查性能。还确定了纳入母体特征的附加价值。
使用国家出生体重图表,37-42 周新生儿体重<第 3 百分位、<第 5 百分位和<第 10 百分位的比例分别为 3%、6%和 12%,体重<2500 克的比例为 2%。对于 10%的假阳性率,直接概率方法检测出生体重<第 10 百分位的新生儿的检出率为 51%,而两个 EFW 参考图表的第 10 百分位截断值的检出率分别为 32%和 48%。添加母体特征可将检出率提高 2%至 53%。
该经过验证的筛查晚期 SGA 胎儿的方法优于使用生长曲线的传统方法。通过添加母体特征,这种筛查方法为定制图表提供了一个有利的替代方案。