Global eHealth Unit, Department of Primary Care and Public Health, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Department of Integrated Early Childhood Development, Capital Institute of Paediatrics, Beijing, China.
J Glob Health. 2013 Dec;3(2):020404. doi: 10.7189/jogh.03.020404.
An important issue for mHealth evaluation is the lack of information for sample size calculations.
To explore factors that influence sample size calculations for mHealth-based studies and to suggest strategies for increasing the participation rate.
We explored factors influencing recruitment and follow-up of participants (caregivers of children) in an mHealth text messaging data collection cross-over study. With help of village doctors, we recruited 1026 (25%) caregivers of children under five out of the 4170 registered. To explore factors influencing recruitment and provide recommendations for improving recruitment, we conducted semi-structured interviews with village doctors. Of the 1014 included participants, 662 (65%) responded to the first question about willingness to participate, 538 (53%) responded to the first survey question and 356 (35%) completed the text message survey. To explore factors influencing follow-up and provide recommendations for improving follow-up, we conducted interviews with participants. We added views from the researchers who were involved in the study to contextualize the findings.
WE FOUND SEVERAL FACTORS INFLUENCING RECRUITMENT RELATED TO THE FOLLOWING THEMES: experiences with recruitment, village doctors' work, village doctors' motivations, caregivers' characteristics, caregivers' motivations. Village doctors gave several recommendations for ways to recruit more caregivers and we added our views to these. We found the following factors influencing follow-up: mobile phone usage, ability to use mobile phone, problems with mobile phone, checking mobile phone, available time, paying back text message costs, study incentives, subjective norm, culture, trust, perceived usefulness of process, perceived usefulness of outcome, perceived ease of use, attitude, behavioural intention to use, and actual use. From our perspective, factors influencing follow-up were: different caregivers participating in face-to-face and text message survey, sending text messages manually, participants responding incorrectly, and technical issues. Participants provided several recommendations for improving follow-up and we added our views to these.
This is the first study to evaluate factors influencing recruitment and follow-up of participants in an mHealth study in a middle-income setting. More work is needed to assess effectiveness of our suggested strategies. This work would improve evaluation of mHealth interventions.
移动医疗评估的一个重要问题是缺乏样本量计算的信息。
探索影响移动医疗研究样本量计算的因素,并提出提高参与率的策略。
我们探讨了在一项基于移动医疗短信数据收集的交叉研究中影响参与者(5 岁以下儿童的照顾者)招募和随访的因素。在乡村医生的帮助下,我们从登记的 4170 名儿童中招募了 1026 名(25%)照顾者。为了探索影响招募的因素,并为提高招募提供建议,我们对乡村医生进行了半结构化访谈。在 1014 名纳入的参与者中,662 名(65%)对第一个关于参与意愿的问题做出了回应,538 名(53%)对第一个调查问题做出了回应,356 名(35%)完成了短信调查。为了探索影响随访的因素,并为提高随访提供建议,我们对参与者进行了访谈。我们将参与研究的研究人员的观点纳入其中,以使研究结果具有背景意义。
我们发现了几个影响招募的因素,这些因素与以下主题有关:招募经验、乡村医生的工作、乡村医生的动机、照顾者的特征、照顾者的动机。乡村医生提出了一些招募更多照顾者的建议,我们在这些建议中加入了我们的观点。我们发现了以下影响随访的因素:手机使用情况、使用手机的能力、手机问题、查看手机、可用时间、偿还短信费用、研究激励、主观规范、文化、信任、过程的感知有用性、结果的感知有用性、感知易用性、态度、使用意愿、实际使用。从我们的角度来看,影响随访的因素有:不同的照顾者参与面对面和短信调查、手动发送短信、参与者错误回复、以及技术问题。参与者提出了一些改进随访的建议,我们在这些建议中加入了我们的观点。
这是第一项在中等收入国家评估移动医疗研究中参与者招募和随访影响因素的研究。需要进一步研究来评估我们建议策略的有效性。这项工作将改善移动医疗干预措施的评估。