Malskat Wendy S J, Poluektova Anna A, van der Geld Cees W M, Neumann H A Martino, Weiss Robert A, Bruijninckx Cornelis M A, van Gemert Martin J C
Department of Dermatology, Erasmus Medical Center, Burgemeester's Jacobplein 51, 3015 CA, Rotterdam, The Netherlands,
Lasers Med Sci. 2014 Mar;29(2):393-403. doi: 10.1007/s10103-013-1480-5. Epub 2013 Dec 24.
Endovenous laser ablation (EVLA) is a commonly used and very effective minimally invasive therapy to manage leg varicosities. Yet, and despite a clinical history of 16 years, no international consensus on a best treatment protocol has been reached so far. Evidence presented in this paper supports the opinion that insufficient knowledge of the underlying physics amongst frequent users could explain this shortcoming. In this review, we will examine the possible modes of action of EVLA, hoping that better understanding of EVLA-related physics stimulates critical appraisal of claims made concerning the efficacy of EVLA devices, and may advance identifying a best possible treatment protocol. Finally, physical arguments are presented to debate on long-standing, but often unfounded, clinical opinions and habits. This includes issues such as (1) the importance of laser power versus the lack of clinical relevance of laser energy (Joule) as used in Joule per centimeter vein length, i.e., in linear endovenous energy density (LEED), and Joule per square centimeter vein wall area, (2) the predicted effectiveness of a higher power and faster pullback velocity, (3) the irrelevance of whether laser light is absorbed by hemoglobin or water, and (4) the effectiveness of reducing the vein diameter during EVLA therapy.
静脉腔内激光消融术(EVLA)是一种常用且非常有效的治疗下肢静脉曲张的微创疗法。然而,尽管已有16年的临床应用历史,但目前尚未就最佳治疗方案达成国际共识。本文所提供的证据支持这样一种观点,即频繁使用者对其基础物理学知识的了解不足可能是造成这一缺陷的原因。在本综述中,我们将探讨EVLA可能的作用方式,希望对与EVLA相关的物理学有更深入的理解,能促使人们对有关EVLA设备疗效的说法进行批判性评估,并有助于确定最佳治疗方案。最后,我们将提出一些物理学观点,对一些长期存在但往往缺乏依据的临床观点和习惯进行讨论。这包括以下问题:(1)激光功率的重要性与每厘米静脉长度(即线性静脉腔内能量密度,LEED)以及每平方厘米静脉壁面积所使用的激光能量(焦耳)缺乏临床相关性之间的关系;(2)更高功率和更快回撤速度的预期效果;(3)激光是被血红蛋白还是水吸收的无关性;(4)EVLA治疗期间减小静脉直径的效果。