Massoglia Michael, Firebaugh Glenn, Warner Cody
University of Wisconsin-Madison.
Pennsylvania State University.
Am Sociol Rev. 2013 Feb;78(1). doi: 10.1177/0003122412471669.
Each year, more than 700,000 convicted offenders are released from prison and reenter neighborhoods across the country. Prior studies have found that minority ex-inmates tend to reside in more disadvantaged neighborhoods than do white ex-inmates. However, because these studies do not control for pre-prison neighborhood conditions, we do not know how much (if any) of this racial variation is due to arrest and incarceration, or if these observed findings simply reflect existing racial residential inequality. Using a nationally representative dataset that tracks individuals over time, we find that only whites live in significantly more disadvantaged neighborhoods after prison than prior to prison. Blacks and Hispanics do not, nor do all groups (whites, blacks, and Hispanics) as a whole live in worse neighborhoods after prison. We attribute this racial variation in the effect of incarceration to the high degree of racial neighborhood inequality in the United States: because white offenders generally come from much better neighborhoods, they have much more to lose from a prison spell. In addition to advancing our understanding of the social consequences of the expansion of the prison population, these findings demonstrate the importance of controlling for preprison characteristics when investigating the effects of incarceration on residential outcomes.
每年,超过70万名罪犯从监狱获释并重新回到全国各地的社区。先前的研究发现,与白人出狱者相比,少数族裔出狱者往往居住在更为弱势的社区。然而,由于这些研究没有对入狱前的社区状况进行控制,我们并不清楚这种种族差异中有多少(如果有的话)是由于逮捕和监禁造成的,或者这些观察结果是否仅仅反映了现有的种族居住不平等。使用一个具有全国代表性且能长期跟踪个人情况的数据集,我们发现只有白人在出狱后居住在比入狱前明显更为弱势的社区。黑人及西班牙裔则不然,而且总体上所有群体(白人、黑人及西班牙裔)在出狱后也并非居住在更差的社区。我们将监禁影响方面的这种种族差异归因于美国种族社区不平等的高度存在:由于白人罪犯通常来自条件好得多的社区,他们因入狱服刑而失去的更多。除了增进我们对监狱人口扩张的社会后果的理解之外,这些发现还表明,在调查监禁对居住结果的影响时,控制入狱前特征的重要性。