Liu Lu, Wei Jianrong, Huang Jiping
Departement of Physics and State Key Laboratory of Surface Physics, Fudan University, Shanghai, China.
PLoS One. 2013 Dec 23;8(12):e82771. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0082771. eCollection 2013.
Because the movement of stock prices is not only ubiquitous in financial markets but also crucial for investors, extensive studies have been done to understand the law behind it. In particular, since the financial crisis in 2008, researchers have a more interest in investigating large market volatilities in order to grasp changing market trends.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: In this work, we analyze the breakouts and breakdowns of both the Standard & Poor's 500 Index in the US stock market and the Shanghai Composite Index in the Chinese stock market. The breakout usually represents an ongoing upward trend in technical analysis while the breakdown represents an ongoing downward trend. Based on the renormalization method, we introduce two parameters to quantize breakouts and breakdowns, respectively. We discover scaling behavior, characterized by power-law distributions for both the breakouts and breakdowns in the two financial markets with different power-law exponents, which reflect different market volatilities. In detail, the market volatility for breakdowns is usually larger than that for breakouts. Moreover, as an emerging market, the Chinese stock market has larger market volatilities for both the breakouts and breakdowns than the US stock market (a mature market). Further, the short-term volatilities show similar features for both the US stock market and the Chinese stock market. However, the medium-term volatilities in the US stock market are almost symmetrical for the breakouts and breakdowns, whereas those in the Chinese stock market appear to be asymmetrical for the breakouts and breakdowns.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: The methodology presented here provides a way to understand scaling and hence volatilities of breakouts and breakdowns in stock price dynamics. Our findings not only reveal the features of market volatilities but also make a comparison between mature and emerging financial markets.
由于股价变动在金融市场中不仅普遍存在,而且对投资者至关重要,因此人们进行了广泛研究以了解其背后的规律。特别是自2008年金融危机以来,研究人员对调查大幅市场波动以把握不断变化的市场趋势更感兴趣。
方法/主要发现:在这项工作中,我们分析了美国股票市场的标准普尔500指数和中国股票市场的上证综合指数的突破和跌破情况。在技术分析中,突破通常代表持续的上升趋势,而跌破代表持续的下降趋势。基于重正化方法,我们分别引入两个参数来量化突破和跌破。我们发现了标度行为,其特征是两个金融市场中的突破和跌破均呈现幂律分布,且幂律指数不同,这反映了不同的市场波动。具体而言,跌破的市场波动通常大于突破的市场波动。此外,作为新兴市场,中国股票市场在突破和跌破方面的市场波动均大于美国股票市场(成熟市场)。此外,美国股票市场和中国股票市场的短期波动呈现相似特征。然而,美国股票市场中期波动在突破和跌破方面几乎对称,而中国股票市场在突破和跌破方面似乎不对称。
结论/意义:本文提出的方法提供了一种理解股价动态中突破和跌破的标度以及波动的途径。我们的发现不仅揭示了市场波动的特征,还对成熟金融市场和新兴金融市场进行了比较。