Center on the Developing Child, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts;
Pediatrics. 2014 Feb;133(2):312-26. doi: 10.1542/peds.2013-1632. Epub 2014 Jan 13.
Childhood adversity is associated with physiologic dysregulation across multiple biological systems; however, relatively little is known about whether these changes are reversible with intervention. The objective of this review was to examine evidence for the effectiveness of interventions to promote healthy cortisol regulation in children. We selected articles from English-language publications in PubMed and EBSCO databases through 2012. Two independent reviewers assessed articles against eligibility criteria. Eligible studies were randomized controlled or quasi-experimental studies designed to improve relationships, environments, or psychosocial functioning in children and examined cortisol as an outcome. We identified 19 articles. There was substantial heterogeneity across studies with regard to age, selection criteria, intervention design, cortisol assessment, and follow-up duration. Eighteen of the 19 articles reported at least 1 difference in baseline cortisol, diurnal cortisol, or cortisol responsivity between intervention and control participants. Importantly, however, there was remarkable inconsistency with regard to how the interventions influenced cortisol. Therefore, studies that included a low-risk comparison group (n = 8) provided critical insight, and each found some evidence that postintervention cortisol levels in the intervention group approximated the low-risk comparison group and differed from children receiving usual care. In conclusion, existing studies show that cortisol activity can be altered by psychosocial interventions. These findings are promising, not only because they indicate physiologic plasticity that can be leveraged by interventions but also because they suggest it may be possible to repair regulatory systems after childhood adversity, which could inform strategies for reducing health disparities and promoting lasting improvements in health.
儿童期逆境与多个生物学系统的生理失调有关;然而,干预是否能改变这些变化还知之甚少。本综述的目的是研究促进儿童健康皮质醇调节的干预措施的有效性的证据。我们通过 2012 年在 PubMed 和 EBSCO 数据库中的英文出版物中选择了文章。两名独立的审查员根据资格标准评估了文章。合格的研究是随机对照或准实验研究,旨在改善儿童的人际关系、环境或心理社会功能,并将皮质醇作为结果进行检查。我们确定了 19 篇文章。这些研究在年龄、选择标准、干预设计、皮质醇评估和随访时间方面存在很大的异质性。19 篇文章中的 18 篇报告了干预组和对照组之间皮质醇、日间皮质醇或皮质醇反应性的基线皮质醇至少有 1 个差异。然而,重要的是,这些干预措施对皮质醇的影响存在显著的不一致性。因此,包括低风险对照组(n = 8)的研究提供了重要的见解,每个研究都发现了一些证据表明干预组的干预后皮质醇水平接近低风险对照组,与接受常规护理的儿童不同。总之,现有研究表明,皮质醇活性可以通过心理社会干预来改变。这些发现很有希望,不仅因为它们表明可以通过干预利用生理可塑性,而且因为它们表明在儿童期逆境后可能有可能修复调节系统,这可以为减少健康差距和促进健康的持久改善提供策略。