Address correspondence to Christine E. Bishop, Heller School for Social Policy and Management, Brandeis University, 415 South Street, Mailstop 035, Waltham, MA 02254-9110. E-mail:
Gerontologist. 2014 Feb;54 Suppl 1:S46-52. doi: 10.1093/geront/gnt163.
To develop implications for research, practice and policy, selected economics and human resources management research literature was reviewed to compare and contrast nursing home culture change work practices with high-performance human resource management systems in other industries. The organization of nursing home work under culture change has much in common with high-performance work systems, which are characterized by increased autonomy for front-line workers, self-managed teams, flattened supervisory hierarchy, and the aspiration that workers use specific knowledge gained on the job to enhance quality and customization. However, successful high-performance work systems also entail intensive recruitment, screening, and on-going training of workers, and compensation that supports selective hiring and worker commitment; these features are not usual in the nursing home sector. Thus despite many parallels with high-performance work systems, culture change work systems are missing essential elements: those that require higher compensation. If purchasers, including public payers, were willing to pay for customized, resident-centered care, productivity gains could be shared with workers, and the nursing home sector could move from a low-road to a high-road employment system.
为了为研究、实践和政策提供启示,我们回顾了一些经济学和人力资源管理研究文献,以比较和对比养老院文化变革工作实践与其他行业的高绩效人力资源管理系统。在文化变革下,养老院的工作组织与高绩效工作系统有很多共同之处,高绩效工作系统的特点是赋予一线员工更大的自主权、自我管理团队、扁平化的监督层次结构,以及希望员工利用在职获得的特定知识来提高质量和定制化水平。然而,成功的高绩效工作系统还需要对员工进行密集的招聘、筛选和持续培训,并提供支持有选择性招聘和员工承诺的薪酬;这些特点在养老院部门并不常见。因此,尽管与高绩效工作系统有许多相似之处,但文化变革工作系统缺少了一些关键要素:需要更高薪酬的要素。如果包括公共支付者在内的购买者愿意为定制化、以居民为中心的护理付费,那么生产力的提高就可以与员工共享,养老院部门就可以从低路就业系统转向高路就业系统。