Addict Behav. 2014 Jan;39(1):225-30. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2013.10.013.
Few cross-cultural studies have investigated the self-change process with substance abusers. This study examined commonalities and differences related to the self-change process with Spanish speaking self-changers in Spain and the United States (U.S.) who reported recovering from an alcohol or drug problem on their own (i.e., without formal help or treatment) for ≥1 year.
Advertisements were primarily used to recruit participants. There were 56 participants in the final sample (Spain, n=29; US; n=27). Participants provided demographic and substance use history information and completed the Drug Use History Questionnaire, Reasons for Change Scale, the Life Events Checklist, and a checklist for maintenance factors after recovery.
Significantly more self-changers from the U.S. met DSM IV-TR criteria for alcohol dependence, reported significantly more life events in the year prior to recovery and significantly more maintenance/support events in the year after their recovery than their counterparts in Spain. The majority of participants' recoveries involved abstinence. Some alcohol abusers, however, report successfully engaging in low-risk drinking with no consequences(50% Spain; 22% U.S.), and some drug abusers in Spain (23%) reported a few days per year of very little drug use.
The two groups of Spanish speakers represented very different cultures, and those from the U.S. came from several countries in the Southern hemisphere. The results of this study suggest that even though people speak the same language that does not mitigate against cultural differences. Additional studies of the process of self change with larger participant samples are needed to better inform the development and provision of interventions for Spanish speakers with alcohol and drug use disorders across different cultures and countries.
鲜有跨文化研究调查过物质滥用者的自我改变过程。本研究调查了西班牙和美国(美国)讲西班牙语的自我改变者在自我改变过程中的共同之处和差异,这些自我改变者报告称在没有正式帮助或治疗的情况下(即,自行)摆脱了酒精或药物问题至少 1 年。
主要使用广告来招募参与者。最终样本中有 56 名参与者(西班牙,n=29;美国;n=27)。参与者提供人口统计学和药物使用史信息,并完成药物使用史问卷、改变原因量表、生活事件清单以及恢复后维持因素清单。
与西班牙的自我改变者相比,来自美国的自我改变者更符合 DSM-IV-TR 酒精依赖标准,报告在恢复前一年有更多的生活事件,在恢复后一年有更多的维持/支持事件。大多数参与者的康复涉及戒酒。然而,一些酗酒者报告说成功地进行了低风险饮酒,没有任何后果(西班牙 50%;美国 22%),而西班牙的一些吸毒者(23%)报告说每年有几天几乎不使用毒品。
两组讲西班牙语的人代表了非常不同的文化,而来自美国的人来自南半球的几个国家。这项研究的结果表明,尽管人们说同一种语言,但这并不能减轻文化差异。需要对具有酒精和药物使用障碍的西班牙语使用者的自我改变过程进行更多的研究,以更好地为不同文化和国家的西班牙语使用者提供干预措施的制定和提供。